Natalie has been taught how to act like a woman, but not how to be a person. This distinction lies at the center of Yesteryear, a novel by Caro Claire Burke that portrays what happens to women who fully submerge themselves in the role that patriarchy demands of them, and how that submersion damages not only them but everyone around them. The novel follows Natalie, an eighteen-year-old young woman from a small Christian community who goes to Harvard University and meets Caleb, the son of a wealthy U.S. senator. She marries him, becomes pregnant during her sophomore year, and drops out of college. After giving birth to her first child, Natalie sinks into depression, worsened by the strain of the people around her. She decides to build a farm with her unambitious husband, but the project fails despite financial support from her father-in-law. She eventually starts an Instagram account presenting herself as a “tradwife,” a term used to describe married women who post on social media about their traditional lifestyle (“Tradwife”). Through this persona, she conceals her mental struggles and earns five million followers. But as her account grows, the performance becomes increasingly difficult to separate from her actual identity.
To me, this is the story of a woman who was never taught to become a full person in the first place. Mary Wollstonecraft, in A Vindication of the Rights of Woman, argued that women “ought to endeavour to acquire human virtues (or perfections) by the same means as men, instead of being educated like a fanciful kind of half being” (106). Natalie illustrates the result of the kind of education Wollstonecraft criticizes in The Vindication of the Rights of Woman. Natalie’s “education” from her mother and her Christian community revolved around vanity and blind obedience to patriarchy, rather than cultivating her own morality. As a result, Natalie became judgmental rather than wise, obedient rather than virtuous, and, ultimately, incomplete, “like a fanciful kind of half being.”
Though Natalie appeared virtuous, first to her mom and her small Christian community, and later to her five million followers watching her curated life online, her virtue was defined by how well she conformed to the expectations placed upon her. Wollstonecraft claims, “it is a farce to call any being virtuous whose virtues do not result from the exercise of its own reason” (86). She argues that virtue cannot be inherited or imitated, it must be reasoned into being. For Wollstonecraft, virtue requires independent reasoning; for Natalie, however, virtue has always conformed to the expectations of those around her. For Wollstonecraft, real education is the cultivation of a mind capable of independent judgment: the ability to think, question, and act from conviction. “The most perfect education,” she writes, is the ability “to strengthen the body and form the heart” (86). Instead of this kind of education, Wollstonecraft observes that women are handed a false promise, “told from their infancy that a little knowledge, softness of temper, [and] outward obedience will obtain for them the protection of man” (84). This, Wollstonecraft argues, is not women’s natural state, but a cultural convention ingrained in women before they are old enough to question it.
Yesteryear shows this indoctrination through Natalie. When she is leaving her small town to go to Harvard, Natalie’s mother emphasizes, “I am serious, Nattie. Be nice” (Burke 43). A two-word instruction that asks nothing of her except pleasantness. Like Wollstonecraft’s “little knowledge, softness of temper,” it teaches Natalie that her security depends on obedience. At college, Natalie encounters women whose lives deviate from what she has been taught a woman’s life should look like. She harshly criticizes these women, whom she calls the “Angry Women” (Burke 247), because she cannot understand their different life choices. Her judgment reveals that much of what she considers virtue has been borrowed from her mother and her faith rather than developed through her own reasoning. This becomes especially clear when Natalie smugly tells her former roommate, Reena, that she got married to the son of a wealthy man, is pregnant, and is dropping out of college. Reena, meanwhile, remains at school, navigating relationship problems and interning at a consulting firm. Rather than seeing Reena’s choices as merely leading to a different life, Natalie views it as an inferior one.
Nineteen-year-old Natalie believes she has done the virtuous thing by getting married, getting pregnant, and dropping out of college. Though this belief quickly crumbles after she gives birth and experiences depression, her depression worsens as she discovers her husband’s lack of ambition and intelligence, qualities she had once attributed to him. Determined to conceal what she deems as his emasculating shortcomings, Natalie decides to build a farm with him. She turns to her father-in-law, Doug, for five million dollars to fund the project. He agrees, but demands she have more kids with his son (Burke 167). This demand exposes the cost of the “good Christian” life Natalie has been taught to pursue. She believes marriage and motherhood would provide her security as her mother and community had taught her through the values of “outward obedience” (Wollstonecraft 84). Instead, she finds herself dependent on men who demand her obedience and her body for her financial security. Even in the midst of severe postpartum depression, Natalie accepts Doug’s demand because she has never been taught to imagine an alternative means of securing her future.
Wollstonecraft argues that women are actively denied the knowledge that would allow them to recognize patriarchy for what it is: a system that benefits men. She claims, “Tyrants and sensualists are in the right when they endeavour to keep women in the dark, because the former want only slaves, and the latter a play-thing” (Wollstonecraft 90). Yesteryear dramatizes how this darkness is also sustained through women themselves, from mother to daughter. Natalie recalls her own mother perched at the edge of the hospital bed when Natalie told her how disoriented giving birth felt, to which her mother replied, “you’re going to be back to feeling like yourself in no time” (Burke 97). Years later, Natalie reflects on these lies but refuses to resent her mother for them: “I don’t blame her for it or for waiting until just the right moment to let me in on the secret.” Natalie now understands the secret her mother was keeping was itself a lie, a “shared agreement between women to insist back and forth in endless conversation” that they were experiencing the life they had been promised when, in fact, they were only pretending (233). As Natalie’s post-partum depression worsens, both her mother and mother-in-law confess their struggles with motherhood and with performing the piety and submission expected of them. Rather than questioning these expectations, Natalie watches how they live within these expectations and unquestioningly imitates them because she has never learned to decide for herself what she needs. Natalie ultimately sees their lies as “a shared agreement between women to insist back and forth in endless conversation” that they actually are experiencing the life they were promised, when in fact they’re just pretending (233). Wollstonecraft assumes an outside tyrant is required to keep women “in the dark” (90); Yesteryear shows the darkness maintaining itself with women keeping each other inside it.
Wollstonecraft emphasizes women’s lack of education as a problem of physical confinement as much as intellectual restriction. She states, “the sedentary life which they are condemned to live, whilst boys frolic in the open air, weakens the muscles and relaxes the nerves” (Wollstonecraft 109). Yesteryear shows this confinement sustaining through the next generation as something closer to erasure than restriction. Natalie, consumed by performing her traditional lifestyle for her audience, leaves her eleven-year-old daughter, Clementine, homeschooled through an underdeveloped curriculum given by her husband. When Shannon, Natalie’s Instagram producer, tells Clementine that she wants to travel and see the Pacific Ocean, Clementine looks at her in confusion and asks, “Ocean, what’s that?” (Burke 289). Wollstonecraft’s “sedentary life” is a woman kept from learning about and moving through a world she at least knows exists. Clementine’s confinement is a generation further along: she does not know the world she has been kept from exists at all.
For both Wollstonecraft and Natalie, men are permitted a range of interests: music, sports, ideas to turn into physical exertion, all of which enrich and shape the mind. Women, by contrast, are funneled into a single narrow role, one that fixes their attention on the smallest and most superficial parts of themselves. Late one night, Clementine finds her mother rehearsing her smile in front of a mirror, after being told her smile makes her unapproachable. “I’m practicing being likable,” Natalie tells her. When Clementine asks what that means, Natalie shows her daughter how to smile (Burke 231). Rather than questioning why she must perform pleasantness for an audience at all, Natalie passes down the mechanics of the performance to her daughter. Wollstonecraft claims that women are “taught from their infancy, that beauty is woman’s sceptre, the mind shapes itself to the body, and, roaming round its gilt cage, only seeks to adorn its prison” (84). By calling beauty a “gilt cage,” Wollstonecraft suggests that being valued for one’s appearance becomes a form of confinement. By teaching Clementine how to please others rather than encouraging her to question why she needs to, Natalie passes down the same expectations that were placed on her.
The most damaging consequence of Natalie’s education is what it does to her judgment, especially her judgment of other women. Because Natalie was never taught to reason her way to virtue, she measures other women against the standards patriarchy has given her. When Natalie’s sister, Abigail, confides that she wants to go on birth control, Natalie does not reason through her sister’s very legitimate concerns. She shames her instead. When Abigail reveals she wants to divorce her abusive, alcoholic husband, Natalie responds with contempt. “You will be a single mother of five living on food stamps,” she snaps. “That is what you will be. You don’t even have a job history, Abigail. You’d be lucky if they hired you to bag groceries with the teenagers in town” (Burke 201). Natalie is enforcing the same arrangement Wollstonecraft names: women must trade knowledge and independence for a man’s protection, even as that arrangement is actively endangering Abigail’s and her children’s lives.
Natalie’s instability escalates rapidly after Shannon enters her life. Shannon points out all the things Natalie has been trying to hide from her Instagram followers. When Shannon confronts Natalie with the realities of her broken marriage and fractured home, and berating her for how she treats her own family, Natalie chokes her. To Wollstonecraft, Natalie’s violence is inevitable. She argues that “the mind will ever be unstable that has only prejudices to rest on, and the current will run with destructive fury when there are no barriers to break its force” (Wollstonecraft 84). Shannon’s confrontation shatters the reality Natalie has constructed online, and Natalie’s response is force. The judgment that once expressed itself only in her mind, in comments about “the Angry Women,” has nowhere left to go but outward, physically, onto the person telling her the truth.
In 1792, Wollstonecraft insisted it was “time to effect a revolution in female manners and restore to them their lost dignity” (133). Yesteryear illustrates what happens when that revolution never happens. Natalie is not a villain. She is a product of a mother who taught her to “be nice” instead of to think, a community that measured her worth by her compliance, and a father-in-law who made the terms of her protection explicit: her body, in exchange for his money. Wollstonecraft insists an education is supposed to establish an enriched mind capable of making decisions and making distinctions between good and bad. She states, “strengthen the female mind by enlarging it, and there will be an end to blind obedience” (Wollstonecraft 90). The damage of Natalie’s lack of education moves from her to women around her. It moves outward as her blind obedience to patriarchy turns into contempt for Reena, cruelty toward Abigail, and violence against Shannon. And it moves downward, into Clementine, who has been kept away from the world so completely that she cannot even name what she has been denied.
Reading Wollstonecraft alongside Natalie’s story leaves me with a lesson above all, one I intend to take into the next chapter of my own education. I don’t want to be taught a role so completely I mistake it for who I am as a person. Throughout this book, one thing becomes clear: Natalie lacks discernment. Natalie is denied the education that develops an inner standard by which she can decide what kind of person she wants to be. Because she never learned to distinguish between virtue and obedience, she confuses conformity with goodness and judgment with morality. To educate is to give one the ability to question the place they have been given. In the town I immigrated from, women are expected to get married and have kids before they have had the chance to become a full person. Education has given me the space to break through those expectations and decide who I want to be beyond those expectations. As I head into the next stage of my own education, this is the distinction I want to hold onto: the difference between being taught what to become, and being taught how to think. To make mistakes and learn from them, to “have various employments and pursuits” (Wollstonecraft 112), to disobey when necessary, to explore, to establish what I value through experience, to learn how to be a person before a woman.
Works Cited
Burke, Caro Claire. Yesteryear. Alfred A. Knopf, 2026.
“Tradwife.” Cambridge Dictionary, Cambridge University Press & Assessment, dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/tradwife. Accessed 31 Aug. 2026.
Wollstonecraft, Mary. A Vindication of the Rights of Men; A Vindication of the Rights of Woman; An Historical and Moral View of the French Revolution. Edited by Janet Todd, Oxford UP, 2008.
