Editor’s Note:
This reflection essay was written by Teagle Humanities Fellow Azaleah Mendoza in August, 2026. During the summer before her first year in college, Azaleah worked with a writing mentor while she read transformative texts, developed her own thoughts and opinions about the world she inhabits, and practiced college-level writing. All of the essays produced in the Teagle Humanities Fellowship are the works of young scholars, and as such, reflect craftsmanship and ideas still in progress, and are written in the spirit of open inquiry.
Azaleah Mendoza

Azaleah Mendoza

Azaleah Mendoza is from Guam and graduated from George Washington High School. She participated in the I Chalan Mo’na KFF program, where she developed a stronger interest in reading and thinking more deeply about complex ideas. One of her favorite texts from the program was Frederick Douglass’s “What to the Slave is the Fourth of July,” which shaped how she thinks about freedom and self-determination. She currently attends the University of Guam, where she hopes to continue developing her voice as both a writer and thinker. In her spare time, she enjoys writing poetry as a way to reflect and process her thoughts, as well as playing the piano and singing. She is especially interested in exploring ideas about identity, relationships, and personal growth through both reading and writing.

The Price of Belonging: Identity, Survival, and What We Surrender in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein and Nella Larsen’s Passing

“These novels give me a way to think about a problem that still exists: people continue to live under expectations about who they should be, how they should behave, and which parts of themselves will be welcomed. We can change because experience teaches us something valuable, but we can also change because we have learned what version of ourselves other people prefer. The difficult part is recognizing the difference.”

Belonging is often treated as something inherently good. To belong is to be recognized, understood, and accepted as part of something larger than oneself. But I have begun to wonder what happens when that acceptance has conditions. What happens when being accepted requires us to become more acceptable first? The question is not only about whether we are allowed into a community, but about what we are expected to change before we are welcomed there. Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein and Nella Larsen’s Passing approach this problem from radically different directions. Shelley’s Creature is rejected because others decide what he is from the moment they see him, while Larsen’s Clare Kendry survives by controlling what others believe about her. One cannot escape the identity imposed upon him; the other constructs an identity that society will accept. Reading them together, however, makes me question the idea that identity is either something we freely choose or something society simply gives us. Instead, both novels suggest that identity develops through a negotiation between the self and those willing or unwilling to recognize it. That realization leads me to a more personal question: Am I changing because I’m growing, or because I’ve learned that who I am is unacceptable? Shelley and Larsen do not give me an easy answer. Instead, they make me question how much of becoming myself is actually becoming more acceptable to everyone else.

Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein first introduces this question through Victor Frankenstein, a young scientist consumed by the desire to uncover the secret of life. After assembling a living being from human remains, Victor expects his creation to fulfill the dream that consumed him. He carefully chooses the Creature’s appearance, explaining, “His limbs were in proportion, and I had selected his features as beautiful. Beautiful! Great God!” (Shelley 43). The abrupt shift from “Beautiful” to “Great God!” captures Victor’s immediate rejection of what he has created. The Creature’s features have not changed; Victor’s perception of them has. Once the body comes to life, Victor can no longer see the beauty he originally intended to create. Instead, he focuses on the Creature’s appearance, describing his “yellow skin” and “watery eyes” before emphasizing his “shrivelled complexion and straight black lips” (43). Yet Victor’s description is not entirely negative. He also notices the Creature’s “lustrous black” hair and “pearly whiteness” of his teeth, qualities that form a “more horrid contrast” with the features he finds disturbing (43). What matters is that the Creature has done nothing to deserve this judgment. Victor decides what the Creature is before he has the opportunity to speak or act. His first lesson about humanity is thus rejection. Shelley makes his appearance more than a physical characteristic; it becomes an identity imposed upon him by the person who created him. The Creature enters the world without knowing who he is, and Victor immediately teaches him that he is something to be feared.

After Victor abandons him, the Creature is left to discover humanity without anyone to guide him. He eventually finds shelter near the De Lacey family and secretly watches them from a distance. This becomes important because after learning from Victor that his appearance makes him something to fear, the Creature begins to look to other human beings to understand what it means to belong. He does not initially know why he is different or what makes someone worthy of companionship, so he studies the De Laceys and learns about human connection by watching their lives. He explains, “when they were unhappy, I felt depressed; when they rejoiced, I sympathized in their joys” (Shelley 100). His response shows that he is not simply observing the family; he learns to recognize their sadness and happiness before he has anyone with whom to share his own. By listening to their conversations, he also learns to communicate, explaining, “I improved in knowledge of language; I could understand and imitate almost every word that was spoken” (106). Language gives him a way to understand the people he watches, but it does not give him a place among them. The more he learns about human relationships, the more clearly he understands what he is missing. His education is therefore also an education in exclusion: he learns what it means to be human by watching people who will not yet see him as one. 

As the Creature learns more about human connection, he becomes increasingly aware of what he has been denied. He eventually seeks out Victor because he wants the person responsible for creating him to acknowledge his suffering. When they meet, he does not immediately attack Victor; instead, he asks him to listen and attempts to explain how his experiences have changed him. Reflecting on the person he once was, the Creature tells Victor, “I was benevolent and good; misery made me a fiend” (Shelley 87). The contrast between “benevolent and good” and “fiend” reveals the difference between how the Creature understands his original nature and how Victor judged him from the moment he came to life. He remembers himself as capable of compassion before repeated rejection taught him to see himself as an outsider. His confrontation with Victor, therefore, gives him something he has been denied since his creation: the opportunity to speak for himself and explain who he believes he is. At the same time, the Creature cannot claim that rejection excuses everything he does afterward. After being repeatedly refused companionship, he becomes violent, killing William Frankenstein, Victor’s younger brother, and later causing the deaths of other people connected to Victor. These actions complicate his suffering because he is not simply a passive victim of other people’s judgments. Shelley gives him responsibility for his choices while still asking the reader to consider how those choices arose from prolonged isolation and rejection. His violence does not prove that Victor was right to call him a monster from the beginning; instead, it shows how a person can be shaped by the way others treat them without being completely defined by it. The Creature wants recognition from the person who created him, but the person who should have given him a place in the world is the first person to deny him one.

The Creature’s confrontation with Victor also reveals how deeply his experiences of rejection have shaped how he sees himself. This changing understanding of himself becomes clearest when he sees his reflection in a pool. He recalls, “but how was I terrified, when I viewed myself in a transparent pool!” (Shelley 101), and later refers to himself as “the monster that I am” (102). The word “terrified” suggests more than simple disgust with his appearance. After spending so much time observing human beings, the Creature has learned what love, companionship, family, and human beauty look like, but he has learned all of these things from outside the community he wants to join. When he sees his own reflection, he realizes that he does not resemble the people whose lives he has been studying. His physical difference becomes something he has learned to interpret as evidence that he is fundamentally separate from them. The Creature’s self-understanding is therefore shaped by the same exclusion that has prevented him from belonging in the first place. He has learned what belonging looks like without ever being allowed to experience it himself, making it difficult to separate what he has discovered about himself from what the world has taught him to believe. His story shows that when a person is continually treated as an outsider, exclusion can become part of the way that person understands who they are.

If Frankenstein asks what happens when society decides someone is unacceptable before knowing who they are, Nella Larsen’s Passing asks what happens when someone can belong only by concealing their true identity. Set within the racial and social divisions of 1920s America, the novel follows Irene Redfield and Clare Kendry, two light-skinned Black women who navigate racial identity differently. In the novel, “passing” refers to a Black person being perceived by white society as white, allowing them access to social spaces, relationships, and privileges that would otherwise be restricted. Irene and Clare knew each other as teenagers in Chicago, but they lost contact after Clare left and eventually married John Bellew, a white man who believed that she was white. Years later, they unexpectedly meet again in New York, where Clare reveals to Irene that she has been passing as white. Passing gives Clare access to a socially privileged life that would otherwise be restricted to her, but it also separates her from the Black community she once belonged to. Clare begins seeking out Irene because she misses the community and relationships she left behind, eventually asking Irene to join social gatherings with other Black people. In her letter to Irene, she writes, “For I am lonely, so lonely” (Larsen 11). Her loneliness reveals that this privileged life has not given her the belonging she expected. She has gained access to a world that accepts her because it believes she is white, yet she remains separated from the people who know the identity she conceals. Unlike the Creature, Clare can influence what others see, but the identity she presents is something she must continually protect. Larsen therefore shifts the question from what happens when society imposes an identity upon you to what happens when society rewards you for hiding part of the identity you already have.

The conditions of Clare’s belonging become clearer when she is forced to confront what would happen if the identity she conceals were ever seen. Clare has built her life around Bellew’s belief that she is white, but the reader learns just how hostile his views are before he ever discovers the truth about her. While Clare is visiting Irene and spending time with Irene’s Black friends, Bellew joins them without realizing that Clare is Black. During the gathering, Irene asks him whether he dislikes Black people, and he responds, “I don’t dislike them, I hate them” (Larsen 40). He then declares, “No niggers in my family” (41). Bellew believes that Clare shares his racial identity, so he speaks openly about Black people in front of his own wife without realizing that she belongs to the group he is condemning. Although Clare maintains an appearance of serenity, Irene notices a “quick apprehensive look” on her face (41), revealing that Bellew’s words have unsettled her. Clare does not challenge him or reveal the truth; instead, she remains composed while listening to her husband condemn the very racial identity she has hidden from him. Her controlled reaction reveals the pressure created by her passing: she cannot openly respond to his prejudice without risking the identity that protects her place in his life. The irony is that Bellew’s acceptance of Clare exists alongside his hatred of Black people. He does not know that the woman he loves is Black, so his acceptance is based entirely on what he believes she is. Clare, thus, experiences a form of belonging that depends not on being fully known, but on remaining unseen. Larsen uses Bellew’s prejudice to show why Clare cannot simply reveal herself and expect the same acceptance to remain. Her concealment is not meaningless deception; it is a response to a society in which revealing her identity could fundamentally change how she is treated.

Irene Redfield adds another layer to Larsen’s argument because she does not pass as Clare does, yet she is still deeply invested in maintaining a particular identity and social stability. After reconnecting with Clare, Irene allows her to increasingly integrate into her social circle, even though she understands the danger of Clare moving between a Black community that knows her identity and a white husband who does not. Clare, however, is not simply being carried along by circumstances. She deliberately uses her ability to pass to move between these worlds, choosing when to reveal herself and when to conceal herself. Her passing has become a skill that gives her access to a life she could not otherwise have, even as it creates risks she cannot fully control. Clare also becomes interested in Irene’s husband, Brian, which intensifies Irene’s fear that the stability she has built is being threatened. Irene’s feelings toward Clare, therefore, cannot be reduced to jealousy. She is fascinated by Clare, emotionally drawn toward her, suspicious of her, and frightened by what Clare’s presence might disrupt. At one point, Irene thinks that she is “caught between two allegiances, different, yet the same” (Larsen 98). At this moment, Irene is weighing her loyalty to the life she has built against her growing attachment to Clare and the threat Clare poses to her marriage, social position, and sense of security. The contradiction captures the tension between what Irene wants to protect and what Clare draws her toward. Although Irene and Clare navigate racial identity differently, both women are conscious of what they must protect and what they risk losing to maintain their place in the worlds they inhabit. Irene does not have to hide her racial identity as Clare does, but she carefully manages her marriage, motherhood, social position, and respectability. Clare’s return forces Irene to confront desires and fears that she would rather keep contained. Larsen, therefore, makes identity larger than passing: Clare controls what others see to cross a racial boundary, while Irene controls her surroundings to keep her own life within boundaries she considers safe. Both women are negotiating the expectations attached to belonging, even though they do so in very different ways.

The danger that Clare has been navigating throughout the novel finally becomes unavoidable near its end. When Bellew discovers Clare’s racial identity, the social world she has carefully constructed becomes unstable. At a gathering in Irene’s apartment, Bellew arrives unexpectedly and sees Clare among the Black guests. He realizes that his wife has been passing as white and that the identity he has trusted her to have is not the identity she actually possesses. His discovery carries the weight of everything he has already said: the reader knows that this is the same man who has already made his hatred of Black people clear and believes Black people have no place in his family. Clare’s carefully constructed life is therefore placed in danger precisely because Bellew’s prejudice has already established what her racial identity means to him. During the confrontation inside Irene’s apartment, Clare moves toward one of the windows and falls to her death. Larsen never explicitly establishes whether Irene or Bellew caused the fall. Irene later thinks, “What happened next, Irene Redfield never afterwards allowed herself to remember. Never clearly” (Larsen 111). The uncertainty leaves responsibility unresolved, but the circumstances surrounding Clare’s death make one thing clear: the belonging she gained through passing was never secure. It depended upon keeping hidden the very identity that Bellew had already shown he considered unacceptable.

Exploring both texts together changes the way I understand belonging. The Creature and Clare appear to occupy opposite positions: the Creature is judged immediately by his physical appearance, while Clare uses the ambiguity of her appearance to shape how others understand her. Yet both stories reveal the same unsettling truth: perception can matter more than reality. The Creature is compassionate, intelligent, and capable of learning, but his appearance determines what others believe he is before they know anything about him. Clare, meanwhile, is Black, but her appearance allows Bellew to perceive her as white, giving her access to a life that depends upon his misunderstanding. In both novels, belonging depends less on who these characters actually are than on whether others recognize or accept the identity they present. The difference is that the Creature has no control over the perception imposed upon him, while Clare develops the ability to manipulate perception in order to survive and gain access to a world that would otherwise exclude her. Her agency does not make her situation less dangerous; instead, it shows how much skill and constant control are required when belonging depends on remaining believable to others. The Creature learns what belonging looks like while remaining outside it; Clare experiences belonging only as long as others continue to believe she is someone else.

This is where my original question begins to change. The Creature does not simply “become” a monster, and Clare does not simply “become” white. Both learn how the world sees them and adjust their understanding of themselves within those expectations. Their stories make me question whether adaptation is always growth. Sometimes changing means learning from experience, becoming more considerate, or discovering something about ourselves that we could not have understood before. But change can also come from learning what version of ourselves other people will tolerate. Growth allows the self to expand; changing only because we believe who we are is unacceptable can make us smaller.

That distinction is what makes these novels relevant to my life and to the world around me in 2026. I do not need to argue that Shelley and Larsen were predicting specific ways people navigate identity today, such as through social media, to see their relevance. Their novels give me a way to think about a problem that still exists: people continue to live under expectations about who they should be, how they should behave, and which parts of themselves will be welcomed. We can change because experience teaches us something valuable, but we can also change because we have learned what version of ourselves other people prefer. The difficult part is recognizing the difference.

I return, then, to the question I began with: What happens when being accepted requires us to become more acceptable first? The Creature was never given the chance to experience belonging without first being judged by his appearance, while Clare was never given a society in which her racial identity carried no consequences. Reading them together has made me realize that growth does not mean refusing to change. Growth should change me. Other people should change me. Experience should change me. But if every change begins with the belief that I must become more acceptable before I deserve to belong, then I am no longer simply becoming myself. I am learning how to disappear in ways other people can accept.

Works Cited

Larsen, Nella. Passing. 1929. Introduction by Brit Bennett, Signet Classics, 2021.

Shelley, Mary. Frankenstein. 1818. Bantam Books, 2003.