It is impossible to escape the impression that people commonly use false standards of measurement–that they seek power, success and wealth for themselves and admire them in others, and that they underestimate what is of true value in life. – Freud, Civilization and Its Discontents
Every generation faces questions about identity, freedom and what it truly means to live a meaningful life. In 2026, these questions have become more connected to capitalism and consumer culture. Social media encourages people, especially the youth, to build personal brands, companies, social media pages for profit and convince their consumers that happiness can be bought and identity is something to be purchased and success is often measured by productivity rather than character.
This results in people struggling to distinguish who they truly are. Herman Melville and Sigmund Freud approached the problem from different perspectives. Melville explores how capitalist labor can alienate people from their humanity while Freud argues that civilization requires individuals to suppress parts of themselves in order to maintain social order and to keep a facade of fitting in with everybody else. Together these authors show that consumer culture is a pretty big threat and it’s not just because of overconsumption but because we lose authenticity and individuality.
If Herman Melville were looking at the world right now he would probably see it as an illusion factory that isolates people more than ever based on one of his stories “The Piazza.” In the story the narrator sits safely on his porch looking through a telescope at a distant glamorous golden cottage that could be interpreted now as our phones which gives us curated sparkling images of ideal lives, luxury products, different travel destinations or false narratives and products being sold to us. Over consumption relies on magic: you click a button and a box arrives, the same way Melville would compare the narrator thinking a fairy lived on the mountain in a beautiful cottage when in reality there wasn’t. Capitalism hides the human cost of production behind shiny screens or billboards.
If Melville were living in 2026 I think he would recognize something familiar in the modern pressure to always be productive. People are often told they should always be working towards something. Students are expected to build impressive resumes, keep up with an excessive amount of work, get good grades, and have to know what they want to do with their future. Before they even develop a frontal lobe, workers are expected to be available beyond their working hours and people are encouraged to turn their hobbies into top businesses. Even rest sometimes feels like something that just needs to be justified. In “Bartleby, the Scrivener,” Bartleby’s refusal therefore becomes more than a strange reaction to his job. It can represent a person’s desire to exist outside of what society expects them to produce. The narrator cannot understand Bartleby because he is accustomed to judging people according to their usefulness. When Bartleby stops doing his work the narrator does not know what to do with him. Bartleby is no longer functioning as an employee the narrator expects him to be.
This reveals one of Melville’s central concerns: what happens to a person when society only knows how to value the person through their role or productivity. Bartleby becomes difficult to understand because he refuses to define himself through his job. Melville shows how isolated he becomes after refusing to work. Bartleby eventually remains in the office instead of leaving; the narrator discovers that Bartleby has been living there and describes him as a motionless man. This image is important because Bartleby’s resistance does not immediately give him freedom. Instead he becomes increasingly separated from everyone around him. His refusal allows him to reject the system but it does not automatically give him a sense of purpose or freedom.
This idea connects strongly to consumer capitalism. Today people are not only workers, but they are also consumers. Modern advertising constantly suggests that purchasing a certain product can help a person become more attractive, successful, confident or different. In this way capitalism can influence identity: instead of asking “who am I” a person can be asking “what do I have? How do other people see me?” or “what new product can make me feel different from others?” The promise of consumer culture is that individuality can be purchased. A person can buy a certain style of clothing, technology, car, or lifestyle and use it to communicate who they are. However this can create a contradiction. If millions of people are buying the same products to appear unique, then the products that are supposed to express individuality can actually create conformity and a sense of “uniqueless-ness”.
Freud provides another way to understand this problem. In Civilization and its Discontents, Freud argues that human beings have desires that cannot always be freely expressed because civilization requires rules and restrictions. People cannot simply do whatever they want in order for society to function; individuals have to control some of their impulses and accept limitation. Freud writes that “civilization is built entirely on renunciation of instincts” (Freud, 75). This idea is important because it shows that the conflict between the individual and society exists long before modern consumer culture.
Freud also explains that civilization gives people benefits while taking away some of their freedom. He writes “What we call our civilization is largely responsible for our misery” (Freud, 74). Freud is not necessarily arguing that civilization should be abandoned. Instead, he is showing that there is a cost of living in an organized society. People gain safety, relations, and structure, but they also lose control and a part of themselves. At first Freud’s argument seems different from Melville’s focus on work and the economic system, since Freud focuses more broadly on human psychology and civilization. However their ideas connect when we consider how social expectations influence identity. Melville shows what can happen when a person refuses to participate in the economic system. Freud explains why people normally accept social systems even though systems restrict them. People need to have secure relationships and stability. Because of those needs, individuals often sacrifice some of their personal desires in order to fit into a “perfect” society.
But let’s take a pause. I’d imagine Melville, if he were to almost be having a conversation with us, would tell us that Bartleby’s refusal is important precisely because it makes everyone else uncomfortable. The other characters know how to understand a worker who works but they do not know how to understand someone who refuses to participate. Bartleby forces the narrator to confront an uncomfortable possibility: maybe a person’s value can’t be measured by their usefulness alone. Maybe there’s something more.
Then if we turn to Freud, what if the problem is bigger than capitalism? What if we’ve always struggled with pressure and losing a sense of self? Freud would have a point that people do not need capitalism alone to experience social pressure. In fact families, schools, religions, governments and communities all establish expectations about how people should behave and how we should act in a society. A person cannot simply follow every desire without affecting other people. Civilization requires compromise; this means that individuality was never meant for complete freedom. Freud also discusses the “oceanic feeling” (Freud, 35) the feeling of oneness one feels where you believe you’re one with everything around you. Although as you grow you are begging to separate yourself from that feeling, it tends to come back in short glimpses of deep concentration and meditation. This discussion of the oceanic feeling adds another important layer to this conflict between the individual and society. The oceanic feeling is a sense of being connected to everything around oneself without the normal boundary that separates the individual from the rest of the world. Freud explains that one person describes his feeling as a sensation of eternity, a feeling of something limitless and unbounded (Freud, 24).
Although Freud does not accept the feeling as proof of religious truth, the idea is useful when thinking about individuality. Modern consumer culture constantly encourages people to define themselves as separate and unique through what they wear, own, or accomplish, and display especially through their wealth. The oceanic feeling suggests the opposite possibility that maybe a meaningful life does not always require us to constantly prove that we’re different from everybody else around us. This idea unexpectedly connects with Bartleby. Bartleby refuses to perform the identity that the workplace gives him but he also does not replace it with another carefully made identity. He simply says “I would prefer not to.” His refusal is a bit unsettling to the people around him because they expect him to be this defined worker with a specific purpose, but he doesn’t give them that satisfaction. I wouldn’t argue that people should completely lose their individuality, but instead the oceanic feeling makes me think that individuality and connection do not have to be opposites. A person can have a unique sense of self and recognize their worth without the need of displaying or consuming or feeding into a capitalistic society.
Ultimately Melville and Freud help to reveal two sides of the same problem: Melville shows that alienation that can occur when a human being is treated as a worker while Freud shows the psychological cost of living within a civilization that requires people to control their desires and suppress their true self. Their ideas remain relevant because modern society has found new ways to create these pressures today. People not only are expected to work and follow these rules but they also are encouraged to constantly display themselves or improve themselves and consume products that supposedly express who they are, when in fact they’re hiding their true individual selves. After reading these two authors, I would define individuality not as a complete freedom from society but as the ability to participate in society without allowing it to completely determine who you are. In a world where almost everything can become a product, the most important thing we can do is to protect a part of ourselves that can’t be bought or sold, to live without constantly feeling the need to display ourselves. Because we know who we are and we shouldn’t need a product or advertising to tell us who we are.
Works Cited
Freud, Sigmund. Civilization and its Discontents. W. W. Norton & Company, 2010.
Melville, Herman. Herman Melville, Billy Budd, Bartleby and Other Stories. Penguin Classics, 2016.
