Editor’s Note:
This reflection essay was written by Teagle Humanities Fellow Manxi Han in August, 2026. During the summer before her first year in college, Manxi worked with a writing mentor while she read transformative texts, developed her own thoughts and opinions about the world she inhabits, and practiced college-level writing. All of the essays produced in the Teagle Humanities Fellowship are the works of young scholars, and as such, reflect craftsmanship and ideas still in progress, and are written in the spirit of open inquiry.
Manxi Han

Manxi Han

Manxi Han is a philosopher-activist who was born in Ann Arbor, Michigan and currently resides in New Haven, Connecticut. In the summer of 2025, she participated in Yale’s Citizens Thinkers Writers Program; her favorite texts from that program were “The Ones Who Walked Away From Omelas” and “Antigone.” She graduated from Wilbur Cross High School in 2026 and currently attends Yale University, where she plans to major in philosophy. Manxi enjoys playing the clarinet, reading classic novels, ice skating, and getting involved in climate activism.

Trump’s Immigration Crackdown: Communal Aggression, Authoritarianism, and a Sick Society

“Using Freud’s insight on the psychological basis of individuals and communities, and Foucault’s analysis of how penal systems play into systems of power throughout history, we must race against the authoritarian clock, breaking out of our communal illness and building a foundation for a country that rests not on hatred, fear, and aggression, but on the innate sense of connection with others we all hold inside.”

Since the beginning of 2026, over 350,000 immigrants have been arrested, detained, and deported from the country by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). This campaign of brutality, which blatantly brandishes racist overtones, centers around Trump’s promise to conduct the “largest deportation operation” in American history. This attack on immigrant communities, framed as a crackdown on “migrant crime,” is rife with abuse: it features the brutal use of force, intimidation, and scare tactics by ICE, a lack of accountability and oversight, and a slew of civil rights violations. This moment is much more than a rare blip in our country’s history; by placing Sigmund Freud, the pioneer of the groundbreaking psychoanalytic branch of psychology, and Michel Foucault, a brilliant philosopher whose work has overturned Enlightenment political theory, in conversation with each other, we can see that our country is headed down the slippery slope toward authoritarianism. At this critical moment, tyranny and communal aggression are strengthening each other to create a vicious cycle of scapegoating, intimidation, violence, surveillance, and brutality. Trump’s so-called “immigration crackdown” is only one visible symptom in a broader national sickness eroding this country, its values, and the principle of democracy.  

In Civilization and Its Discontents, Sigmund Freud boldly delineates a cynical, hedonistic world-view where primal instincts in pursuit of maximizing personal pleasure clash with the altruistic foundations of civilization. Among the most prominent of these urges is the instinct to be aggressive towards others, which Freud argues “constitutes the greatest impediment to civilization” (110). Continually, a dialectical struggle occurs between selfish, aggressive interests and communal interests that prioritize common welfare over that of the individual. Uncontrolled aggression guarantees the disintegration of society, so society must redirect the urge in one of two ways: either each individual’s “aggressiveness is introjected, internalized” in the form of a watchful superego, or self-torturing conscience, or, more importantly, a common enemy is created to be the object of aggression (114). According to Freud, community cohesion can be maintained “so long as there are other people left over to receive the manifestations of their aggressiveness” (98). Societal self-destruction is averted when aggression, which demands to be released, is directed towards the destruction of an enemy.

The United States is a paradigm of this type of instinct diversion, where external and internal enemies are manufactured to redirect aggression and promote national cohesion. Within the country, America has repeatedly created dichotomies drawing rigid lines between “us” and “them,” alienating groups for scapegoating purposes, from people of color to women to Muslims to the LGBTQ community. Within the broad category of immigrants, every single wave of immigration throughout American history has produced a wave of xenophobia and nativist sentiment. The common enemy is woven into the fabric of our nation’s history, and additionally, it has been the object of political weaponization. 

Michel Foucault’s Discipline and Punish shows just that within the framework of the penal system. Foucault traces the evolution throughout history of systems of punishment from that of the spectacle, an overt display of a sovereign’s personal and political power, to that of a nearly perfectly efficient system of individualized surveillance, manipulation, and discipline. The power of the penal system in the age of absolutism lay in its creation of an object for public ridicule, outrage, fear, and hatred: the criminal. During highly visible and dramatized public rituals of punishment, the criminal confronted the “contained anger of the people” (Foucault 58). Public execution was accompanied by an “unbelievable exaltation of hate” on the part of the audience (260). Viewing this ritual from a Freudian lens, dangerous communal aggression was sublimated through a relatively harmless ritual whose terms were directly dictated and controlled by the sovereign. The criminal was not only a common enemy that warded off the threat of unchecked aggression, but a representation of the powerlessness of a subject in front of the sovereign. Thus, the double efficacy of the criminal made it into a perfect scapegoat. 

Trump’s designation of immigrants as criminals is a calculated move based on this understanding. Ad nauseam, Trump has repeated unsubstantiated claims that immigrants are murderers, rapists, “snakes that bite,” “coming from jails and mental institutions,” and “killing Americans en masse,” making full usage of the criminal as a potent object of communal aggression and a display of political power (Pennington). By connecting immigrants specifically to crime, Trump’s actions parallel those of the nineteenth-century French ruling class, who continually affirmed that crime is “almost exclusively committed by a certain social class[…]  that crime is itself due rather to the fact that one is in society as an alien, that one belongs to a bastardized race” (Foucault 275-276). Trump’s “illegal aliens” fit the description perfectly as a distinct minority group that can be made into the token of crime and criminality, using which he can reap the benefits of satisfying the aggression of his base, maintaining his political power, and most importantly, testing out his authoritarian arsenal. 

The parallels between the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown and absolute monarchs’ use of the penal system are beyond striking. Foucault describes the old tradition of punishment as a “theatre of hell,” a “political ritual,” a spectacular display of “the physical, material, and awesome force of the sovereign” (46, 47, 50). Similar to a military parade proclaiming victory over an external enemy, public punishment proclaimed the victory of the sovereign over all that opposed, or could potentially oppose, their rule. The optics of ICE agents are precisely engineered to be highly visible and suggestive of a military operation: from tactical gear to masks to helmets to new electric shock gloves, ICE agents are spectacles of fear and intimidation. The comparisons do not end there: just as public punishment rituals were a way for “the king [to] take revenge for an affront to his very person” (Foucault 48), Trump treats ICE as his “personal force to be deployed against American cities perceived as hostile to his interests” (Shah). And just as old laws were “written, secret, subjected,” and “the penal investigation was a machine that might produce the truth in the absence of the accused” based on the arbitrariness of the sovereign (Foucault 37), Trump has systematically targeted detained immigrants’ legal aid, including defunding Acacia, a national organization that provides pro-bono legal assistance for detained children. According to Foucault, we must “regard punishment as a political tactic” (130); Trump’s actions against immigrants are a warning sign that the American power structure is taking an authoritarian turn. 

Yet the authoritarianism we are headed towards is not the old tradition of an absolute monarchy; Trump combines the theatrics of ICE and a seasoned knowledge of leveraging communal aggression with modern technologies of surveillance and law enforcement to create an even more dangerous power dynamic. In the context of an ever more efficient system of punishment and discipline, Foucault describes a terrifying vision of control: the Panopticon. Derived from English philosopher Jeremy Bentham, the Panopticon is a perfect prison in which all cells are arranged circularly around a central watchtower with shaded windows. Each prisoner “is seen, but he does not see” (Foucault 200). This imbalance of knowledge forces each prisoner to self-surveil, which, for Freud, is a manifestation of the super-ego, an internalization of external authority. “Since nothing can be hidden from the super-ego, not even thoughts,” self-surveillance is even more potent than external surveillance (Freud 117). A Panoptic society is an extension of the Panoptic prison: a place where the technologies of surveillance are perfected to the point of inducing self-surveiling behavior in every citizen throughout society. Discipline and punishment become universal. 

America is not safe from a Panoptic takeover. With ICE’s use of mass surveillance of citizens and non-citizens alike, its “unprecedented project of aggregating Americans’ personal data,” we are at risk of entering into an authoritarian era ruled by the Panoptic gaze (Longsdorf). From tracking phone locations to reading license plates to conducting racial profiling using surveillance technology, ICE has forced immigrant families to self-surveil. In immigrant neighborhoods in Minnesota, for instance, normally bustling stores and restaurants are shrouded in silence as families stay home (Santana). Similarly, activists and journalists are forced to stay vigilant in light of dozens of reported incidents of ICE agents calling them by name and reciting their home addresses (Santana). This nascent Panopticon, where mass government surveillance forces communities to reconfigurate every aspect of their life based on the assumption that they might be watched or arrested at any given time, is reaffirmed by the practice of ICE agents wearing masks: in addition to concealing their identities, these masks have a resemblance to the shaded window of the Panopticon, where the gathering of knowledge and information is one-sided, and the imbalance of power is accentuated through optics. In this way, Trump operates from behind the shaded windows of ICE, “transform[ing] the whole social body into a field of perception” to carry out his immigration crackdown (Foucault 214).

The threat of the Panopticon is thus not localized to immigrant communities. For Foucault, “the guilty person is only one of the targets of punishment. For punishment is directed above all at others” (108). When one group of Americans is targeted, all Americans are threatened because tyranny does not discriminate. The Trump administration’s immigration crackdown is a testing ground for a larger political struggle between Trump’s increasingly authoritarian behavior and all American citizens that abide by the rule of law. Part of the Panoptic vision is the normalization of behavior, where “the whole indefinite domain of the non-conforming is punishable” (Foucault 179). For Trump, the “non-conforming” includes anyone from his political enemies to the LGBTQ community. No group is safe from Trump and the communal aggression he has harnessed for his political benefit. Viewed through the lens of Freudian psychology, this situation resembles what Freud calls “communal neurosis” (147). Our country has become “sick.” Our politics, driven by fear, hatred, and aggression, like an immunocompromised individual, is attacking parts of itself which it believes are foreign. The question becomes this: how do we heal? 

In the first chapter of Civilization and Its Discontents, Freud explores what he calls an “oceanic feeling[…] a feeling of an indissoluble bond, of being one with the external world as a whole” (24-25). This feeling, he argues, is a residue of a time in our psychological evolution before the distinct concepts of “self” and “other,” and the instincts of aggression, emerged. Although Freud is quick to dismiss this feeling as “infantile helplessness” (36), we can glean a glimmer of hope from it: what if, subduing our instinct to create an us/them dichotomy, and with it, an aggression toward external objects and subjects, we embrace this primal connection, this innate solidarity with others? What if, by reconnecting with our dormant “oceanic feeling,” we find a sense of communal cohesion not through unity against a common enemy, but through common values? While this remedy seems viable in Freud’s psychoanalytic system, Foucault shies away from suggesting any way out of Panopticon. Unlike in Freud’s system, aggression is a minute cog in Foucault’s penal, disciplinary, and political machine. Foucault’s political machine has too much inertia, has been embedded too deeply into society, and has too much supporting infrastructure and technology to be stopped by abstract rhetoric about a common “oceanic feeling.” But as it stands, America is not Foucault’s Panoptic society yet. Aggression feeds majorly into Trump’s arsenal of authoritarianism, and if we cut off that fuel, we have a chance at fighting against control, coercion, and the erosion of democracy.

Viewing Trump’s “immigration crackdown” from the lens of Foucault and Freud shows us that we are at an urgent moment where enduring traditions of scapegoating, fueled by communal aggression, are used by a political leader to consolidate power, bypass democratic institutions, and stifle all forms of non-conformity. We are a sick society. The current trajectory of our country is all too clear: even with Trump out of office in the next few years, the groundwork is already laid for the advent of a Panoptic, authoritarian power structure. Using Freud’s insight on the psychological basis of individuals and communities, and Foucault’s analysis of how penal systems play into systems of power throughout history, we must race against the authoritarian clock, breaking out of our communal illness and building a foundation for a country that rests not on hatred, fear, and aggression, but on the innate sense of connection with others we all hold inside. 

Works Cited

Foucault, Michel. Discipline and Punish. Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group, 1995.

Freud, Sigmund. Civilization and Its Discontents. Edited and translated by James Strachey, W.W. Norton, 2010.

Lonsdorf, Kat, et al. “ICE is using mass surveillance on American citizens, activists.” NPR, 2026, https://www.npr.org/2026/03/04/nx-s1-5717031/ice-dhs-immigrants-surveillance-confrontation-deportation-mobile-fortify. Accessed 18 August 2026.

Pennington, Tom, et al. “Fact-checking Trump’s Quotes About Immigrants.” The Marshall Project, 2024, https://www.themarshallproject.org/2024/10/21/fact-check-12000-trump-statements-immigrants. Accessed 18 August 2026.

Santana, Maria. “The life-altering choices immigrant families are making under Trump’s crackdown.” CNN, 15 August 2026, https://www.cnn.com/2026/08/15/americas/immigration-trump-intl-latam. Accessed 20 August 2026.

Shah, Naureen. “We Documented 1,200+ Actions by ICE. Here’s What We Found.” ACLU, https://www.aclu.org/news/immigrants-rights/we-documented-1200-actions-by-ice-heres-what-we-found. Accessed 17 August 2026.