When I was a child, the first lie ever sold to me was Santa Claus: a boisterous old man who brought us gifts if my sister and I had been good that year. There was a present sitting under our tree, labeled from the jolly man himself. It was so easy to accept this tale, to look at the adults around me with open and eager ears. It is easy to look back and think, “I, at my ripe age of adulthood, would never fall for such a tale.”
However, we still live in a world rife with political misinformation. Dr. Lilliana Mason describes the term mega-identity as the integral aspects of one’s identity, like race, religion, ethnicity, gender, etc. However, the issue she notes, is that political affiliation has begun fusing with these mega-identities. When this happens, political debates stop being a matter of disagreement and instead turn into what feels like an attack (Wong and Tomasky). Additionally, this form of political polarization is exploited by algorithms and used to pit Americans against each other. Seeing as more than half of Americans admit to using social media to receive some amount of news (St. Aubin and Liedke), it is no surprise that political community is found there. Echo-chambers of this sort are, what I believe to be, one of the greatest eroders of critical thought. When maintaining community requires parroting similar talking points, while increasingly isolating you from the perceived “other,” independent thought is threatened.
It is easy to point at polarization and believe we are the exception, that we aren’t as gullible, but for me it invokes an interesting thought experiment: if the world gave you every reason to believe something, would you? What if it wasn’t Santa Claus, but instead a political belief, a cultural norm, or a worldview? In an increasingly polarized world–where conformity is rewarded–it’s difficult to ascertain what is true. Plato and Hannah Arendt likely didn’t contend with the question of Santa Claus or contemporary American political polarization, both have unique introspections into critical thought; Plato’s focus lies within the why we believe, where Arendt’s is with failing to think critically about our beliefs.
Plato is one of the most well known philosophers in history. Born in Athens in 427 BCE, while studying under Socrates, Plato devoted his life to the pursuit of truth (Encyclopedia of Philosophy). His most famous book, The Republic, was written around 370 BCE and will be my first literary source. Throughout the book, Plato makes a point to distinguish knowledge from opinion. Often his dialogues use logic to deconstruct arguments, where the term socratic dialogue emerges from. Many of the dialogues focus on Socrates speaking with those who claim to know something, only for his scrutiny to expose contradictions and assumptions within their beliefs. Take Thrasymachus in Book 1 as an example: “I proclaim that justice is nothing else than the interest of the stronger” (338c). Upon hearing this, Socrates requests him to elaborate. This ultimately forces Thrasymachus to think critically about his own beliefs and craft a defensible argument. Socrates’ goal is not to disparage Thrasymachus’ argument, but rather to force him to examine what he actually means. This is one of the first distinctions between simply having an opinion and actually thinking about it.
Book VII describes prisoners who have spent their entire lives in a cave, chained and forced to look forward. When met with the shadows cast by a flame behind them, they “would think that the truth is nothing but the shadows cast by the artifacts” (515c). The Cave Allegory is especially important because it does not portray the prisoners as unintelligent. They have become so knowledgeable about their limited reality that they were never given a reason to question the world that they’ve been shown. And yet, despite their convictions about what is true, they haven’t grasped it. “To [the prisoners], the truth would be literally nothing but the shadows of the images” (515c). This is where I draw a connection between Plato’s Cave Allegory and modern political discourse. Today, our “shadows” take the form of sensationalized headlines, inflammatory debate clips, and interpretations of events given to us by the communities we engage with. These are not necessarily false; but when an issue is only understood through one perspective, one hand-fed to you, it becomes easy to mistake that interpretation for the entirety of reality
Social media can create environments where we’re repeatedly presented with information that confirms what we already believe. If every video we watch comes from people who already share our worldview, we never learn how to thoughtfully, and independently, defend our existing beliefs. We may become more knowledgeable about the shadows without ever turning around to examine what is producing them. Furthermore, misinformation is not always an outright lie; often it can manifest as giving people incomplete pictures of a situation.
Plato’s solution to this problem is an education that focuses on turning the mind toward what it previously could not see. The freed prisoner will not immediately understand the world outside the cave. In fact, the transition is described as painful and confusing as man adjusts to seeing the world in (literally) a new light. Thinking critically is about the personal pursuit of truth, rather than passively consuming everything that is fed to you. Like the man leaving the cave, it requires the willingness to be uncomfortable, to challenge oneself, and to transcend community expectation.
In Eichmann in Jerusalem, Hannah Arendt approaches the subject of critical thought from a different direction. While Plato focuses on how one might distinguish between knowledge and shadows, Arendt is concerned with what happens when people fail to exercise critical thought. Eichmann in Jerusalem is Arendt’s examination of Adolf Eichmann’s trial in 1961. The Nazi official was integral to organizing the deportation of Jewish people during the Holocaust. Arendt’s account details the “banality of evil”: Eichmann was not the extraordinary monster she’d expected, rather an unremarkable man. He portrayed the bureaucrat archetype perfectly throughout his defense, only claiming he was following orders and fulfilling duties assigned to him.
Arendt’s concept of the “banality of evil” was by no means an undermining of the atrocities of the Holocaust, but rather a confrontation of the disturbing possibility that extraordinary evil can be carried out by ordinary people who fail to critically engage with what they are doing. Yes, Eichmann held bad beliefs, but the true horror lied in the fact that the structures and language surrounding him allowed for his judgements to go unchallenged.
The distinction between intelligence and judgement is particularly relevant to modern politics. One can be educated and still conform to community beliefs without examining them; they are not mutually exclusive. Knowing statistics, examples, and arguments are pointless in the pursuit of truth if their framework has already provided a predetermined solution. When you know the solution before you begin, you never feel the need to examine what you are learning and citing. This is artificial nuance; the appearance of intellectual complexity without the necessary process of examination. Unlike what Socrates sought through his dialogues, many develop the ability to defend beliefs without the just as important ability to question them.
Here, Plato and Arendt converge. Plato asks whether we have mistaken appearances and opinions for truth, while Arendt asks what happens when we surrender our ability to judge the systems and beliefs around us. Plato’s prisoner must turn around and discover that his knowledge is incomplete. Arendt’s Eichmann demonstrates the consequences of never questioning the existing framework he participates in. Both suggest simply possessing information is not enough; thinking requires the active willingness to question.
It is important to note, however, neither author suggests critical thought requires the absence of outside influence. No one creates their worldview entirely on their own; in the same way we may learn lies from our community, we also learn fundamental truths. Realistically, we can’t verify every individual fact we encounter. Often discussions will require concessions and grantings to the other side. Often, that which leads us to think critically is learned from others. Therefore, independent thought does not mean social isolation; it only makes you a sheep of the other herd. Instead, independent thought requires awareness of our influences. It necessitates introspection into where our beliefs come from and what assumptions they depend upon. Plato reminds us that we may mistake limited perception with reality, while Arendt reminds us to remain responsible for the judgements we make in our own systems.
The modern danger of social media is not simply that it contains misinformation. Misinformation has existed for centuries. What has changed, however, is the personalization and sheer volume of information that surrounds us. We construct entire communities around shared beliefs which create echo-chambers that only reinforce said beliefs. Disagreement becomes evidence of ignorance, bigotry, or malice. Political affiliation becomes so intertwined with personal identity that changing one’s mind feels like betraying yourself and your community. It’s tempting to believe that we are the exception, that we have escaped the cave. Yet, Plato and Arendt suggest that this confidence should itself be questioned.
I no longer believe in Santa Claus, as most people don’t beyond the age of ten. But the tale still sticks with me, not because of my fear of being on the naughty list, but because of the world that it presented to me. One that only existed as a shadow, where my prisoner chains held the voice of my community. Simply understanding how I fell for that lie does not make me immune to falling for others; I am still surrounded by communities, institutions, and algorithms that try to manufacture my reality.
Independent thought does not require having beliefs that nobody else shares, nor does it require rejecting every authority or influence. Rather, it requires the willingness to examine the beliefs we inherit and to accept the possibility that we may be wrong. In a world where information is increasingly abundant and political conformity is increasingly rewarding, the most important form of independence is not the ability to speak one’s mind, but the ability to examine it.
Works Cited
Arendt, Hannah. Eichmann in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil. Penguin Books, 2006.
Plato. The Republic. Translated with an introduction and glossary by Joe Sachs, Focus Philosophical Library ed., Hackett Publishing, 2007.
St. Aubin, Christopher, and Jacob Liedke. “Social Media and News Fact Sheet.” Pew Research Center, 25 Sept. 2025, www.pewresearch.org/journalism/fact-sheet/social-media-and-news-fact-sheet/.
Wong, Felicia, and Michael Tomasky, hosts. “What Drives Our Political Behavior (with Dr. Lilliana Mason).” How to Save a Country, Roosevelt Institute, 13 Apr. 2023, rooseveltinstitute.org.
