“All men are enemies. All animals are comrades” (Orwell 10). With this declaration, Old Major, the defiant pig leader of the animals in Orwell’s Animal Farm, divides the world into two simple categories, leaving no room for compromise or anything in between. A similar division exists within the United States today. The schism among Americans is drastic, though many people do not take it as seriously as they should. Republicans and Democrats have grown so far apart that the divide has now gone beyond politics and has infiltrated marriages, families, and everyday relationships. Modern-day American politics has a far greater presence in social dynamics. For a long time, politics was largely absent from Americans’ day-to-day lives. This was not always true of the nation’s founding. Political division in America goes back to the 1790s, when Alexander Hamilton’s Federalists and Thomas Jefferson’s Democratic-Republicans clashed over how much power the federal government should hold, a disagreement that gave rise to the very idea of federalism itself. That divide deepened by the mid-1800s, as the modern Republican Party formed in 1854 largely in opposition to the expansion of slavery, setting the stage for the political and regional fractures that led to the Civil War. While political awareness was a thing, people were able to coexist with individuals of the opposite or contrasting political ideologies, and that is no longer the case. The goal should not be forcing everyone to agree; real harmony does not require it. It requires learning to understand another person’s values enough to live with them, even without accepting them as your own. Plato’s Republic and George Orwell’s Animal Farm evaluate how individuals within a society should see themselves within the political landscape. They also show us how to prevent the very separation that they foreshadow and predict, which can happen when citizens refrain from meaningful political participation and challenging leadership that promotes polarization and discourages discourse.
Citizens have a responsibility in a democracy to question what politicians do, whether that means speaking out against injustice or using their voices rather than remaining silent. Plato’s Republic treats this responsibility as the foundation of citizenship itself, arguing that a just society depends on people willing to question rather than simply obey. This is evident from the opening exchanges of the dialogues, where Socrates refuses to accept even reasonable-sounding definitions of justice from Cephalus and Thrasymachus, testing each until it collapses under scrutiny (Plato 331c-336a). Animal Farm shows exactly what is lost when that foundation gives way: the animals stop questioning, conform out of fear, and follow whoever speaks the loudest or promises the most safety. Together, these two texts do not just provide different anecdotes on the social obligation citizens have; they describe the two versions of the same failure: a citizenry that stops asking whether its leaders deserve trust, and a society that pays the price for that silence. Plato shows what citizenship demands of us, the people; Orwell shows what happens the moment we stop delivering it.
The animals in Animal Farm were exploited for their labor and offerings. Many of the animals were forced to give up their eggs, their milk, their physical work and labor in the fields, and were given little to no food in return, or a beating when they resisted. The animals consented to and participated in the sharing of resources for the betterment of their newly formed governance, only to be taken advantage of and bamboozled by their leaders. This mistreatment created frustration, which in turn led the animals to turn on each other even before any revolution began. Old Major uses these protests to justify an absolute claim: all men have become enemies, and unity among animals is the only path towards fairness (Orwell 10). However, that promise of unity did not last. The very division between animal and man meant to unite the farm later resurfaces as a division among the animals themselves. Old Major’s declaration that all animals are comrades is tested within minutes of being spoken. When four rats are spotted and attacked by the dogs, the animals do not simply accept them as comrades; they vote on it (Orwell 10). A claim that was supposedly automatic and universal turns out to require debate and majority approval, which goes on to show that the unity Old Major describes is far more conditional than what he lets on. This matters because a group that has to vote on who belongs to “us” has already accepted that “them” exists as a real possibility; unity that requires a vote was never automatic to begin with. Plato’s Republic also requires sorting people into roles and categories, but that process is meant to be careful and reasoned. Justice, in Plato’s definition, means each person performing the role they are naturally suited for rather than interfering in the work of others, a sorting process aimed at finding where someone genuinely belongs (Plato 433a). Old Major’s speech does the opposite: it declares hostility towards humans first, and only afterward, almost as an afterthought, once the dogs have already attacked, does anyone stop to ask whether the rats might belong on the animals’ side at all.
When the pigs quietly claim the missing milk and the exclusive right to the orchard’s apples, they do not simply take these things; they take them and then manufacture a reason afterward: Squealer insists, falsely, that the pigs dislike milk and apples and endure them solely out of necessity (Orwell 25). This is a privilege disguised as sacrifice; when even that framing fails to satisfy the animals’ grumbling, Squealer abandons persuasion altogether and turns to fear, asking whether anyone wants Mr. Jones to come back (35-36). The grumbling stops immediately, but silence is not the same as agreement; the animals accept the arrangement not because they believe the pigs deserve it, but because they are more afraid of the fact that Mr. Jones might return. As a result, their perceived disdain for Mr. Jones the human outweighed their own anger about being treated unfairly.
This same trend appears in contemporary politics. Politicians frequently campaign on ambitious promises of change, but once in office, many do little to follow through, offering only small, visible gestures of goodwill to keep their supporters satisfied. When their leadership is questioned, many politicians resort to the same tactic as Squealer: warning that the alternative, the opposing party, a return to “how things used to be,” would be far worse. Plato’s Republic describes this exact tactic. A tyrant, Socrates explains, is never satisfied when a real threat has passed; he manufactures new danger so that the people continue to feel that they need him, believing themselves unsafe without his protection (Plato 566a-567a). Similarly, Squealer’s warning about Mr. Jones works the same way: real fear from the past is kept alive artificially, even long after the threat has actually faded, specifically so that questioning the pigs feels too dangerous to risk. Just as the animals stayed silent out of fear of Mr. Jones rather than genuine agreement, many voters continue supporting leaders not because they still believe in the original promises, but because they fear what might happen if the other side takes power instead.
Plato’s Republic argues that a just society requires both citizens who think critically and leaders who are genuinely qualified to rule, not one instead of the other. Socrates’ method throughout his exchanges with Thrasymachus in Book I of the Republic models this; rather than accepting easy answers, he constantly questions, tests, and re-examines ideas, suggesting that curiosity and honest discussion are what allow a society to reach real understanding rather than empty agreement (Plato 331c-336a). At the same time, Plato does not believe leadership should be left to just anyone who is popular or powerful. Rather, throughout the Republic, he argues that those who govern should be thoughtful and capable, concerned with the good of the people they lead rather than their own status, and shaped by an understanding of others’ lives rather than isolated from them (473c–d). When a society has neither of these things, citizens are unwilling to question, and leaders lack real wisdom or concern for others. The result is not stability but collapse. Trust breaks down, conflict replaces cooperation, and the harmony Plato describes as justice disappears entirely. In Animal Farm, Orwell similarly critiques the unwillingness of individuals who blindly follow without truly trying to understand the direction of their leaders, as seen with Boxer, the horse, who responds to every hardship and questionable order with only “I will work harder,” and later adopts the belief that “Napoleon is always right” as a private maxim to resolve any doubt (56).
In Plato’s Republic, Socrates provides an interesting assessment of how individuals become complacent within a society and fail to engage with what is happening around them, not because they do not want to, but in essence, they know no better. The prisoners in the cave have known nothing else their entire lives, chained in place, watching the same shadows repeat, mistaking them for the whole of reality. When one prisoner is finally freed and sees the world outside, he recognizes it as more real and more beautiful than anything the cave offered, and he wants the others to experience it too. But when he returns to share what he has seen, the other prisoners reject him. Plato even suggests they would kill him rather than be persuaded to leave the cave (514a–517a). Animal Farm shows this same instinct in practice. When other animals attempt to raise objections during the meeting, the sheep break into chanting “Four legs good, two legs bad” until the moment for debate has passed; any animal who persists is met with the dogs’ growling (Orwell 48). This mirrors how many people engage with the news and media today. People often stay loyal to the same news channels and sources that confirm what they already believe. There was a time when disagreement meant sitting down, laying out the facts, and actually talking it through with the person in front of you. Political conversations happened face to face, where some basic social pressure kept things civil even when people disagreed. Now, much of that disagreement happens from behind a screen, where accusation and blame replace real conversation. Anonymity and the lack of real consequences make people far more hostile online than they would be in person, since there is no immediate social cost to cruelty when the other person is just a name on a screen. This singular, narrow-minded approach has prevented individuals from engaging with other viewpoints. There was a time when there were only a handful of news outlets and sources available to the public, and yet it can be argued that those sources offered a wide range of perspectives. Now, with the advent of the internet and other channels such as social media and advanced communication forums, sources are abundant. Yet, people still often find themselves consuming a single perspective rather than seeking a breadth of opinions to understand issues locally and around the world.
This “us versus them” dynamic plays out clearly in the divide between Republicans and Democrats today. Rather than approaching disagreement as an opportunity to find common ground, many people treat the opposing party as an enemy to be defeated rather than a group to understand. Old Major’s speech in Animal Farm works the same way from the very beginning: it does not simply say animals and men are different; it says animals are inherently better and deserving, which is what allows total division to feel justified. “Four legs good, two legs bad” (Orwell 48). This phrase, this chant, this slogan is embedded in the animals and is almost hypnotizing in how often it is referenced. One could argue that this is no different within the contemporary American politics of using slogans to indoctrinate a group with political messaging; “Make America Great Again,” “Black Lives Matter,” and “Defund the Police” are short phrases with significant and powerful undertones, regardless of one’s political stance, with a message rooted in pulling an individual in.
Socrates would resist that kind of claim immediately, since his method depends on treating every position, including one’s own, as something that must be defended rather than assumed. Social media accelerates this as algorithms, in the same way as the aforementioned slogans, are built to show each user more of what they already engage with, meaning two people can scroll through entirely different versions of the same news cycle. When a post challenges someone’s existing views, many simply scroll past it rather than engaging with it, reinforcing the same narrow perspective over and over. This is closer to the sheep’s bleating than to genuine disagreement. Scrolling past an opposing view is not so different from drowning it out; both remove the need to respond to it at all whatsoever. Research supports how damaging this pattern actually is. One study found that when people discussed politics only with members of their own party, they became more polarized afterward, not less, while people who spoke with someone from the opposing party did not (Hobolt et al.). This suggests that echo chambers do not simply reflect political division; they actively deepen it, the same way the prisoners in Plato’s cave became more certain of their limited reality the longer they stayed within it (Plato 514a–517a).
The future of this divide rests largely on young people, whether they are taught to talk to one another and actually listen, rather than simply conform to whatever values surround them. Confidence in one’s own ability to think, question, and speak up matters more than blind agreement with any side. That means raising a voice for real concerns, creating spaces, even something as simple as a community hall, where people can argue honestly and still walk away having understood each other a little better. The animals on the farm never had that option; every time a real debate threatened to happen, the sheep were trained to drown it out before it could finish. Plato’s Republic offers what could have stopped that collapse: citizens willing to think for themselves, and leaders who actually deserve the trust placed in them. All hope is not lost. People are already raising their voices; our objective now is to keep that momentum going. Democracy is not something owed to us; it is an action and a blessing, one that carries the responsibility to live alongside people we don’t agree with, and to make that as possible as we can for everyone.
Works Cited
Hobolt, Sara B., et al. “The Polarizing Effect of Partisan Echo Chambers.” American Political Science Review, 2024.
Orwell, George. Animal Farm: A Fairy Story. 75th Anniversary ed., Signet Classics, 2004.
Plato. The Republic. Translated by Paul Shorey, Harvard UP, 1969. Perseus Digital Library.
