Editor’s Note:
This reflection essay was written by Teagle Humanities Fellow Branden Ta in August, 2026. During the summer before his first year in college, Branden worked with a writing mentor while he read transformative texts, developed his own thoughts and opinions about the world he inhabits, and practiced college-level writing. All of the essays produced in the Teagle Humanities Fellowship are the works of young scholars, and as such, reflect craftsmanship and ideas still in progress, and are written in the spirit of open inquiry.
Branden Ta

Branden Ta

Branden Ta is a first-generation Cambodian American born and raised in Los Angeles, California. He participated in Biola University’s Read Well, Live Well program in 2025, where his favorite readings were Plato’s Allegory of the Cave and Sophocles’ Antigone. He graduated from Cerritos High School in 2026 and is currently a freshman at University of Southern California majoring in Philosophy, Politics, and Law with a minor in Entertainment Law. In his spare time, he enjoys playing the guitar, reading comics, and exploring literature and philosophy.

Finding Meaning in a Disconnected World

“Our relationships with others, our sense of belonging, and our shared experiences can become sources of meaning that Freud’s framework does not fully account for. Instead, as Viktor Frankl posited, enduring hardship is precisely what fosters meaning in our lives.”

In 2015, Japan identified over 1.5 million people as “hikikomori,” or people who avoid social interaction. The majority of these hikikomori are young people who haven’t left their bedrooms in months or years at a time (Tamura). In America, teenagers are reporting record levels of loneliness and have had a decrease in happiness and life satisfaction with the percentage of high school teenagers reporting themselves as very happy dropping from 17.9% in 2019 to 12.7% in 2023 (Helliwell). Around the world, there has been a rise in mass protests yet political change is nowhere to be seen. Although these issues seem disconnected, there has been a quiet, widespread turning away from the demands of shared life. A social clock towards college, work, or marriage as well as conforming to the norms of society pressures people toward smaller and safer worlds: a bedroom, a phone, a fictional universe. This isn’t accidental but a response to a deeper problem. A problem with the world feeling that it is increasingly easier to obey the id: the most primitive and unconscious part of the human personality that drives us to satisfy desires immediately.

Freud, in Civilization and Its Discontents, promoted the notion that civilization is built from suppressing our primal urges or our id and listening to our internalized moral standards and social expectations that restrain these impulses or our “superego.” However, conflict between the id and superego can lead to instability. For example, if society becomes too strict, the repressed id may surge forth. Is this what is happening today? 

Online outrage culture where people “hatewatch” shows and movies are examples of people expressing their id’s aggression. Communities gathering to express political discourse is now simplified to yelling, ignoring the superego’s call for reasoned debate. There is now a rise in individualization, as personal desire and identity trumps collective responsibility. This shift from collective action to personal performance is what Freud predicted when repression gets to an extreme, noting how “when an instinctual trend undergoes repression, its libidinal elements are transformed into symptoms and its aggressive components into a sense of guilt” (82).

The expression of the id can most be seen now in the political landscape. Now more than ever there have been countless protests and calls for change yet many of these protests leave no mark in the political landscape, a widespread belief infecting the younger generation that nothing ever happens. As easy as it is to enter a political movement through a hashtag, post, or video, it is even easier to exit and join a new political movement that is trending on social media. Techno-sociologist Zeynep Tufekci explains this phenomenon noting how networked technologies “make it much easier to build up a movement rapidly, but they don’t necessarily build the organizational capacity to sustain it” (xii–xiii). This quick, easy emotional investment allows people to feel involved and gain instantaneous satisfaction for their id. Yet Freud himself notes, the “[id] entails preferring enjoyment to caution and penalizes itself after short indulgence” (16). However this feeling from the id can be expressed in another way. Instead of fighting the system, some people check out entirely. 

When facing societal pressure to conform by marrying or owning a house some people find it easier to shut off and be at home. These people when faced with standards from society or their superego retreat to their house and obey their id. At home they can experience a digital world where they can be more than themselves and live vicariously through their favorite character from a show, movie, or video game. This escapism allows people to feel bigger than life and satisfy their superego. However, this approach serves as less of a solution and more of a gateway to more problems. Shutting yourself off to society leads to less socialization and creates a withdrawn, stagnating society. Freud predicts the future of society by noting how “Future ages will produce further great advances in this realm of culture” (91). But how do you forward mankind if mankind feels like it is moving backward? If the future is worse than the present, retreat almost feels like giving up.

The people who retreat aren’t avoiding pain. They may also be avoiding failure. In the real world, you can try and fail. You apply for jobs and get rejected, work hard yet still fall behind, or ask someone and get turned down. But in your room, there is no rejection. That virtual safety is a trap that once you get used to, makes the real world feel terrifying.

This is where Frankl in Man’s Search for Meaning offers a better path. Frankl would look at the hikikomori and see someone who has made a choice. They are choosing to disconnect. They are choosing not to choose. For Frankl, this is the real tragedy. He argued everything can be taken from a man but one thing: “the last of the human freedoms to choose one’s attitude in any given set of circumstances, to choose one’s own way” (Frankl 66). The person in their bedroom is a person who has given up on finding meaning in the real world.

Frankl would also challenge the online activist. The person who jumps from cause to cause is searching for meaning. But they are looking in the wrong place. Meaning does not come from avoiding pain or seeking instant gratification. Meaning comes from getting through pain, or from love, or work. The activist who truly commits to a cause, who shows up even when it is boring, who does the unglamorous work—that person will find meaning. The person who posts and moves on will not.

Frankl would also say something many may find uncomfortable to hear. The suffering we face is not our enemy. The suffering is where meaning in our lives can come from. The moments in our life that shape us the most were most likely our hard moments. These painful moments help us grow. They make us who we are. Frankl isn’t saying we should seek out suffering but when it comes we should not let it destroy us. Instead, we can use it to become the best version of ourselves. It is a choice and confrontation that we need to face one day.

Moreover, the primary cause of this situation is the feeling of hopelessness produced from not making lasting impacts. Frankl offers something better. He does not promise a life without suffering. He promises that suffering can have meaning. Dedicating ourselves to a cause we believe is our meaning.

However, Frankl’s solution leads us to a new question. Is “finding meaning” just another way of coping, like Freud would say? Or is it something different? Freud would argue that dedicating yourself to a cause or a piece of work is just another distraction from your primal drives. You are still suppressing your id, just in a more acceptable way. Frankl would disagree. He would say that meaning is the only way to truly engage with reality.

I think Frankl is right. Freud’s framework is useful for diagnosing the problem. He accurately describes the tension between individual desire and societal pressure. He explains why people retreat. But Freud does not offer a way out. His view is fundamentally pessimistic. Society can only give us distractions. We can never be fully happy. This leaves us stuck. Being stuck is what we have been seeing everywhere. People running in place or feeling as if the future is hopeless. 

However, even if we agree with Frankl, we have to admit that the world today makes it really hard to follow his advice. Everything is designed to keep us distracted. Social media, streaming platforms, endless notifications—they’re not innocent. They are built to hook us, to give us little dopamine hits that feel good in the moment but leave us emptier afterward. They feed our id the instant satisfaction it craves, with almost no effort required on our part. 

Frankl discusses individual choices, which is understandable as when stripped from all other abilities during the Holocaust, he had the ability to choose. But for modern society, this problem can be solved from more than just the individual. We should build stronger communities that support people and mental health care that’s accessible as well as having educational institutions that help us find meaning in our lives. Frankl has a powerful idea but we ignore the social conditions that allow for retreat to the id to be so appealing in the first place.

Retreating solely to the id offers a primitive escape, yet it ultimately fails to satisfy. While societal pressures can induce feelings of hopelessness and despair, they do not justify regressing to these base impulses. Freud viewed civilization as dependent on suppressing our primal urges and following the moral rules of the superego, making community largely a means to an end: a structure that allows people to live together by restraining the id. Yet community can be more than a means of social control; it can have value in itself. Our relationships with others, our sense of belonging, and our shared experiences can become sources of meaning that Freud’s framework does not fully account for. Instead, as Viktor Frankl posited, enduring hardship is precisely what fosters meaning in our lives. Although societal support is necessary, we must also make the internal choice to choose and transcend these external pressures to find our own meaning.

Works Cited

Frankl, Viktor E. Man’s Search for Meaning. Beacon Press, 2006.

Freud, Sigmund. Civilization and Its Discontents. Translated by James Strachey, W. W. Norton & Company, 2010.

Helliwell, John F., et al. “The Sad State of Happiness in the United States and the Role of Digital Media.” World Happiness Report 2019, Sustainable Development Solutions Network, 2019, https://www.worldhappiness.report/ed/2019/the-sad-state-of-happiness-in-the-united-states-and-the-role-of-digital-media/.

Tamura, Kaoru, et al. “The Hikikomori Population Varies Significantly Depending on the Definition Used: Evidence from a Survey in Kasama, Ibaraki, Japan.” Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences, vol. 79, no. 4, 2025, pp. 204-205, National Library of Medicine, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11962353/.

Tufekci, Zeynep. Twitter and Tear Gas: The Power and Fragility of Networked Protest. Yale University Press, 2017.