Editor’s Note:
This reflection essay was written by Teagle Humanities Fellow Emily Guzman in August, 2026. During the summer before her first year in college, Emily worked with a writing mentor while she read transformative texts, developed her own thoughts and opinions about the world she inhabits, and practiced college-level writing. All of the essays produced in the Teagle Humanities Fellowship are the works of young scholars, and as such, reflect craftsmanship and ideas still in progress, and are written in the spirit of open inquiry.
Emily Guzman

Emily Guzman

Emily Guzman is from Arlington, Texas and participated in the University of Dallas’ College Citizens program in 2025. Two of her favorite texts were The Book of Job and Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics which show the importance of perseverance for how we define ourselves. She graduated from Uplift Infinity Preparatory High School in 2026 and currently attends Middlebury College with an intended major of International and Global Studies. In her spare time, she loves making crafts, being with her cats, and watching films.

A New Day: Reframing Migration Narratives and Strong Education Fundamentals

“While American society is going through these challenges, the future leaves room for us to fulfill the fundamental values of America, and we have the power to challenge our status quo and build our tomorrow, a new day.”

On September 8th, 2025, a new Supreme Court ruling limited protections on the fourth amendment, stating that the type of job someone appears to work, the location of the individual, speaking Spanish or English with an accent, or someone’s appearance serve as probable causes for Immigration and Customs Enforcement, ICE, to stop an individual (Vargas and Sanchez). The ruling lives through everyday lives of many minorities, especially the Latino community. Under it, the Latino community struggles, and so do our communities dependent on each other. People become afraid to work, shop, and attend important events, which affects us all through economic and social effects (Vargas and Sanchez). Cathy Park Hong and Richard Rodriguez, first-generation American authors, shed light on the history of migration and allow us to gain new perspectives on modern America. Building upon Rodriguez, Hong, and my experiences, rather than simply focusing on the economic development brought by migrants, Americans should reframe our narrative on migration, acknowledging U.S. foreign involvement, and analyzing the future of educational systems with a focus on migrant or bilingual children.

Hong allows us to reach one of the many roots of migration as she uncovers the United States’ dark history with her statement about U.S. foreign intervention. While migration is natural, historical events directly impact migration patterns. Hong mentions this in her book, Minor Feelings, when she says  her “ancestral country is just one of the small examples of millions of lives and resources you have sucked” in her statement about Korea directed to the United States (Hong 195). In other instances, the United States has done this through aiding the Guatemalan government in the murder of 200,000 Guatemalan people (Farah), and the Bracero program which normalized poor treatment of Mexican agricultural workers and eventually led to the “immigration problem” within the United States (Mendoza 2019). When discussing migration, we talk about the benefits of migrants, such as diverse foods or a more progressive economy, but we don’t talk about the accountability the United States fails to take. Migrants seek a better life and migrants’ part of the deal is building the economy of the United States; our part is a promising future with proper reconciliation, yet we’ve failed to give them proper reconciliation for our actions. Hong allows us to realize that the United States profits off this system where workers are exploited to develop the country. The “three Chinese laborers” who died for “every two miles of track” allowing for “Manifest Destiny” and westward expansion by European settlers do not appear in the photograph of the completion of the railroad among the White men pictured there (Hong 20). They say a picture speaks a thousand words, and so does the erasure of the Chinese laborers in their contribution to the United States. 

Despite the Chinese laborers’ tremendous support in 1869, not even a century later, Hong shows that “legislators and media characterized Chinese individuals as ‘rats,’ ‘lepers,” dehumanizing the Chinese population to Americans to the point they “couldn’t leave their homes without being spat at, clubbed, or shot in the back” (21). Furthermore, throughout all of this, “Chinese workers were paid 30% less than white workers, forced to segregate within work camps, and pay for their own lodging, food, supplies, and equipment” (“Chinese Labor”). So, while the perspective formed by the United States makes it seem as if we’re helping migrants by giving them an “opportunity,” in reality it’s a fabrication which goes back to the exploitation of workers and U.S involvement in other countries. Because of this, when discussing the relocation of individuals across borders, we should focus on our responsibility and empathy as people and as a nation to acknowledge the horrendous actions of the past.

The past can continue to serve as a motivator for people to relocate to another country for better living conditions, but challenges for migrants do not stop there. Their challenges remain highly relevant to their acclimation to education in terms of language and higher education not only within their generation, but within their future generations. Richard Rodriguez highlights crucial points regarding the weaknesses of the current American educational system in connection to his identity as a Mexican-American in his autobiography The Hunger of Memory. Growing up in the 1980s, Rodriguez lived through earlier stages of bilingual education, however, he was not very fond of it stating that “it is not possible” for children to use their native tongues, or what he refers to as “family language” in school settings (10). In his life, he came to associate the Spanish language with something familiar and private, while English was the language he associated with “gringos,” meaning foreigners (12). Such thoughts during his childhood framed his opposition to the newly-founded bilingual education, as he draws his identity inwards, towards his family, rather than outwards towards society, isolating himself. Because of this, he believes that one’s identity and public perception should be separated, because through incorporation, students don’t have the “right” nor “obligation” to speak the “public language of los gringos” (18). He argues that while he would have felt less intimidated starting school with words familiar to his home, this would delay students’ educational achievements, and the opportunity to receive an education in the same language as other students, English, would be empowerment within itself. 

I feel the similar divisive cultural nature of the classrooms, but I would say the same thing about different programs like the gifted and talented program which establishes a difference between children based on skill level, a difference my friends and I realized. And while I’ve only mentioned this aspect within classrooms, I have noticed that my connection to the Spanish language has been an essential factor of my life. I grew up divided between the English and Spanish language. I remember seeing so many unfamiliar faces as I walked the halls or was playing in the playground during kindergarten. Upon talking to them further, I realized that they were in the classroom next door, while I was in the gifted and talented classroom. I don’t remember the transition from one to the other, but the year after that I was put in bilingual classes. Then, when my test scores were too high, I was placed in the gifted and talented classroom, which didn’t feel like the bilingual classroom that many of my other friends were still in. Because Spanish was my first language and something in common between my friends and in our K-12 majority Hispanic school, I’ve been in a bubble. As I prepare for higher education, I’m navigating my connection to my identity, a challenge for students who also feel heavily reliant/connected to their native tongues. 

As the United States became more progressive with rights and equality, affirmative action was a supplement to its progression, but Rodriguez argues that affirmative action doesn’t reach the root of minorities not being able to access higher education, as it only benefits minority students who were ‘desirable,’ but were still academically held back by years of “inferior schooling” (165-166). Affirmative action was a policy which addressed systemic discrimination and promoted equal access to predominantly white spaces for people of color. Colleges fulfilled their idea of affirmative action by enrolling more minority students, but the underlying issue from previous years of schooling remained. Rodriguez mentions knowing various college students with an inability to perform basic educational skills such as reading or sentence comprehension who, rather than being helped, were humiliated. Higher education is dependent on prior educational skills, and despite a more centralized space for resources, four years is insufficient time to build an individual’s complete educational framework. The issue lies with the foundation, the various years of inferior schooling minorities and migrants are often subjected to. The K-12 system has employed the act of “passing students” through education despite insufficient capability of a student to enact grade-level skills. Ironically, this instead fails them in the future, and as Rodriguez has seen, hinders their ability to succeed in consequent grade levels and higher education, keeping their academic capabilities stagnant. 

Rodriguez was realizing the effects of the gaps in America’s education system then, and decades later, I still see the same gaps in our educational foundations, leading to a cycle of improper education for minorities. The recent teacher shortage has only put more stress on schools and exacerbated issues with underfunded schools, ultimately heavily influencing the students’ learning. Several times throughout my years at an underfunded school, we did not receive core instruction for extended periods. And while I placed my education in my own hands, I cannot say the ongoing cycle has not affected my scholastic confidence. 

Rodriguez, Hong, and my upbringing being a first-generation student as a child of immigrants have shown that our current approach to migration and education doesn’t ensure equality, and has been built off exploitation. From the spaces minorities inhabit to systemic challenges, the educational playing field is unstable, and it all goes back to the history of the foundation of the United States. While American society is going through these challenges, the future leaves room for us to fulfill the fundamental values of America, and we have the power to challenge our status quo and build our tomorrow, a new day. 

Works Cited

“Chinese Labor and the Iron Road – Golden Spike National Historical Park (U.S. National Park Service).” Nps.Gov, 13 Aug. 2023, https://www.nps.gov/gosp/learn/historyculture/chinese-labor-and-the-iron-road.htm.

Constitution Annotated. “U.S. Constitution – Fourth Amendment | Resources | Constitution Annotated | Congress.Gov | Library of Congress.” Constitution.Congress.Gov, Constitution Annotated, https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/amendment-4/. Accessed 11 Aug. 2026.

Farah, Douglas. “PAPERS SHOW U.S. ROLE IN GUATEMALAN ABUSES: In Declassified                 Documents, Diplomats Describe Massacres, CIA Ties to Army.” International Journal of Health Services, vol. 29, no. 4, 1999, pp. 897–99. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/45131825. Accessed 12 Aug. 2026.

Hong, Cathy Park. Minor Feelings: An Asian American Reckoning. One World, 2020.

Mendoza, Mary. “Mexican Farm Labor and the Agricultural Economy of the United States.” History Now, issue 53, Winter 2019. https://www.gilderlehrman.org/history-resources/essays/mexican-farm-labor-and-agricultural-economy-united-states.

Rodriguez, Richard. Hunger of Memory: The Education of Richard Rodriguez: An Autobiography. Dial Press Trade Paperbacks, 1982.

Vargas, Edward D, and Gabriel R Sanchez. “Racial Profiling by ICE Will Have a Marked Impact on Latino Communities.” Brookings, 16 Oct. 2025, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/racial-profiling-by-ice-will-have-a-marked-impact-on-latino-communities/.