Every society conceived by humanity imposes hierarchy. Those at the bottom suffer what they must to serve those at the top. Sometimes, a disturbance shifts this ordinary dynamic into a territory that subverts standard views of power. This essay encompasses instances about three such disturbances. In each of the three texts this essay discusses, a common power dynamic—employer, employee; master, slave; and white, black—is subverted. What happens after these disturbances provides a fascinating subject for reflection.
I.
Herman Melville’s “Bartleby, the Scrivener” is about a boss and his employee. Melville depicts a Wall Street lawyer—the narrator in the story—as the authority figure because of his position as the head of his law office with several employees. Eventually he hires a new scrivener, Bartleby, to assist with mundane, everyday paperwork. At first Bartleby excels in his work and fulfills any expectations of his role. However, Bartleby soon regresses to the point of refusal to do any basic tasks asked of him by his boss. The narrator becomes frustrated but also grows a fascination for why Bartleby refuses. He obsesses over how to understand and reform his scrivener, although Bartleby continually pushes back on any efforts interfering with his passiveness. Melville soon after sentences Bartleby to a hopeless fate: dying alone in a prison cell from self-inflicted starvation due to his refusal to follow lawful commands and accept food. The perception of Bartleby by the narrator shifts, even after his death, when he learns about the pitiful background Bartleby lived through and the pessimistic view of the world he formed.
In his story of Wall Street, Melville subverts the expectancies of power through the introduction of an employee that refuses to obey their boss. Despite his blatant refusal to follow authority, Bartleby becomes a cult-like fascination of the narrator. This irregular concentration of authority gradually shifts the power in their relationship from the boss onto the employee. The narrator understands the shift and argues through a wide variety of thoughts—it is basic humanity to help him; I should just call the police and throw him out; it is my duty under Christian morals to help him—but ultimately reasons into continuing his actions to better Bartleby and become his savior. Although the narrator exhausts every possibility available to him, it never suffices to save Bartleby from his eventual fate. Even in death Bartleby holds control over the narrator’s thoughts, but the power dynamic within the narrator’s relationships returns to its original state with the loss of the outlier.
Similar dynamics play out in Melville’s “Benito Cereno,” which follows the Spanish captain of a slave ship that secretly revolted. The story occurs after an American captain—Delano—boards a stranded Spanish ship and awaits the return of his crew from a day trip hunting blubber. Delano instantly notices the relative freedom of slaves on the ship, but captain Benito Cereno explains to him that the slaves are necessary because of the limited number of Spanish crewmen that remain after disaster at sea. Eventually it is revealed that Babo, the slave always a moment’s distance from Benito Cereno, was the leader of a slave revolt on the ship that concealed itself from Delano while he was on board. The slave revolt is soon nullified in a battle with Delano’s ship, and the slaves return to their roles as prisoners and servants. All members of the revolt are publicly executed on South American soil by the Spanish government after they are transported to the mainland.
Herman Melville once again displays a subversion of expectations based on the audiences’ perception of race. Captain Delano is repeatedly blinded throughout the tale by his personal bias and racist beliefs, allowing Babo and the other slaves to become puppeteers in the shadows with Benito Cereno in the spotlight. Delano places his attention on Cereno to answer any questions and is incapable of seeing any other person as the one in control of the ship. Despite the success of the slaves on the ship, once they are brought to the mainland, the slaves do not simply experience jail or temporary punishment but instead must meet their end by public execution. Even after death the Spanish government displays Babo’s head in a plaza for the world to see. The idea that slaves resisted their chains and became masters initiated a relentless campaign by the government to restore equilibrium to the dynamics of power which race became responsible for, and which they saw themselves as superior in. Melville dedicates the entire final section of the story to showcase a testimony by Benito Cereno about the horrors faced under the rule of slaves. In this report he visualizes how reversing the roles of power makes people that are accustomed to being on top fear any semblance of power outside their hands, especially when it falls into the palms of a different group.
Similarly, Shakespeare’s Othello concerns a black general bewitched by his white subordinate. Othello is a black general highly regarded in Italy for his abilities. He faces opposition often from others, with a primary rallying tool against him being racism. The antagonist, Iago, is a soldier who wanted a higher rank in Othello’s army and seeks to undermine him at any cost out of hatred. Iago utilizes the prejudice against Othello to retrieve support and fare better towards his own goals. High figures in Italy renown Othello for his skill in war, yet it is never enough to erase the bare level of hatred others hold over him along the basis of race alone. Ironically, Othello falls in love with a white woman and the couple is married. Iago successfully uses his influence to convince Othello that his wife is unfaithful. Othello remains trusting of those around him and eventually falls to Iago’s fabrication. Iago further puts his power to use to influence others and destroy opposition, with the ultimate objective to end Othello’s life. By the conclusion of the tale, Othello realized he was tricked into killing his wife, and while Iago is seized for his crimes, the general takes his own life to atone for his foolishness and escape an unbearable fate.
William Shakespeare sets a unique environment which immediately starts by reversing the embedded stereotype between the makeup of an army and its leader. Othello is the figure granted the most authority by the Duke of Venice despite having a different background from others who would hold the same position. Shakespeare immediately showcases the disdain for Othello through racist language and demeanor, but displays how Othello remains ever focused on initiative, duty, and honor, even if it may be the substance that influences him to make a wrong decision. Iago penetrates Othello’s mind and fixates him on the idea of a lying spouse. Once Iago made his lies truth in the mind of his general, he became the dominant influence of power in their relationship, as he managed to mend Othello into believing whatever he said because of trust. Iago keeps his place as the ultimate influence over the general until, after realizing he was lied to about his wife, Othello strikes to rid himself of the bad influence, and upon his failure decides to take his own life. Iago is also stripped of any power that he accumulated, as he was responsible for murder and had his freedom stripped once he was caught.
II.
In each of these stories, conventional power dynamics are subverted. An employee dominates his boss’s thinking; a slave controls his master’s ship; a subordinate brings his superior to ruin. What happens after these disruptions? In each one, the powerful regains their position with help from the broader power system.
Both writers support the idea that while it only takes a single person’s words to subvert hierarchies, it takes a whole community to restore them. Melville constantly publishes the idea that groups are the strongest basis for any person’s adherence to hierarchy. In “Bartleby: The Scrivener,” the narrator compromises with the idea that “Since [Bartleby] will not quit me, I must quit him” to adhere to expected norms (Melville 66). Regardless of if he is fully aligned with the beliefs he spouts in his mind, the narrator cannot internally abandon Bartleby. His actions follow through to this societal pressure, yet he never internalizes the contempt others perceive Bartleby with. His conscience fights over what the best course of action is, yet the narrator falls to the influence of the greater group to exile Bartleby from his place of work and partially contributes to his tragic fate that soon follows.
Melville furthers his belief in group power within the structure of “Benito Cereno.” The slaves act on a united front to minimize suspicion from Captain Delano. Babo especially works to control the narrative of Benito Cereno, which is ultimately the step which quells any misaligning thoughts by Captain Delano. It seems as if this aversive dynamic will continue to exist, until Benito Cereno jumps ship and immediately everything changes. Delano’s ship pursues the San Dominick and after a lengthy assault manages to gain control. All the slaves are put to trial after reaching the mainland, and many are sentenced to death because of their role in breaking their default place in society. Babo is recognized as the figurehead of the rebellion and the Spanish government leverages his position to make a statement through his death. Babo’s head is placed in a plaza for the world to see, displaying not only the might of the Spanish government to crush opposition, but also to reaffirm the idea that the concentration of power will not falter from the current system.
Shakespeare focuses on a similar message of power but takes an opposing approach as to who he believes is most influential. Iago, the antagonist, does not always have this same adherence to a group opinion and schemes from his own mind. His focus remains one sole objective regardless of its means of completion: the downfall of Othello. In a larger capacity, Iago is the force which aims to promote the balance of power seen typically in Shakespeare’s time: the predominant power held by white people and black people at a lower status. Iago acts swiftly, convincing others to follow his path for various motives, yet usually race plays a factor in their decision. After gaining the means to convince Othello his wife is unfaithful, Iago relentlessly implants the idea into Othello’s head until he sees it as doubtless reality. Once Othello realizes the truth, it is far too late. After he follows Iago’s scheme of murder Othello learns of his foolishness. The racism, unreasonable mindsets, and mistrust crush Othello into taking his own life, although Iago’s scheme remains incomplete as he is charged for murder as well. The return to equilibrium based on race and societal places strikes quickly in the story but remains a meaningful lesson on how the greater world will work against someone in a position of power society sees as unfit for their characteristics, and the ultimate harm that comes from restoring to societal norms.
The presence of tragedy at the end of the stories demonstrates the fragile nature of individual power dynamics. The authors create instances where Bartleby dies and a tragic backstory is revealed, slaves are executed and Benito Cereno succumbs to death, and Othello takes his own life to atone for the murder of his innocent wife. All these predicaments represent a return to societal norms: the resistant worker throws away his life, slaves are moved under the will of their master, and the general seeks to atone his honor when he is wrong. Both writers agree that there is a cost when power is returned to its original state after being altered. The hierarchy most of society supports may be the most prominent, yet this does not mean it is the only possible means for the world to function. Fear is a leading factor for why members of society, typically ones who benefit from their level of power, aim to resist change in these dynamics. They must forcefully grab outliers and erase the perception that a different way of life is possible; even if oftentimes this results in an overcorrection which harms every member involved, many members of society see it as a necessity to ensure their current levels of power never falter.
Works Cited
Shakespeare, William. The Tragedy of Othello, the Moor of Venice. Simon & Schuster Paperbacks, 2017.
Melville, Herman. Great Short Works of Herman Melville. Harper Perennial, 1962.
