Editor’s Note:
This reflection essay was written by Teagle Humanities Fellow Arturo Olaez in August, 2026. During the summer before his first year in college, Arturo worked with a writing tutor while he read transformative texts, developed his own thoughts and opinions about the world he inhabits, and practiced college-level writing. All of the essays produced in the Teagle Humanities Fellowship are the works of young scholars, and as such, reflect craftsmanship and ideas still in progress, and are written in the spirit of open inquiry.
Arturo Olaez

Arturo Olaez

Arturo Olaez is from Chicago, Illinois. He participated in the KFF Loyola University Speak Up Democracy program in the summer of 2025, where he explored important political and philosophical ideas through discussion, reading, and civic engagement. His favorite texts from the program were the works of Plato, which encouraged him to think more deeply about democracy, justice, and the role of citizens in society. He graduated from Kennedy High School in 2026 and currently attends DePauw University, where he plans to study Political Science. In his free time, he enjoys running, following soccer, learning about history and politics, and spending time with friends and family. He is grateful for the opportunities KFF provided and excited to continue his academic journey in college.

Compromise or Conviction? What Antigone and Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass Teach Us About Polarization

“Sophocles teaches us that societies become dangerous when people refuse to listen to one another, and especially when leaders refuse to listen to anyone but yes men. Douglass teaches us that societies also become–or remain–dangerous when people refuse to confront injustice. Democracy requires both virtues at the same time. We must remain open to changing our minds when confronted with new evidence, but we should also be willing to defend fundamental principles of justice when those principles are threatened by our laws and policies.”

A few months ago, I was driving through the southside of Chicago when I realized how quickly a neighborhood can change. One block was lined with expensive new apartments, trendy coffee shops, and luxury stores. Just a few minutes away, there were older neighborhoods where families had lived for generations, now struggling with rising rents and the fear of being pushed out. It made me wonder how people living only a few blocks apart could experience such different realities. Growing up in Chicago, I have always known that different neighborhoods can feel like entirely different worlds, but that drive made me think more carefully about why those divisions persist. The more I thought about it, the more I realized this separation extends beyond neighborhoods. Americans increasingly live, work, and consume information alongside people who already experience the world like they do. As political polarization has intensified over the past several decades, these divisions have become increasingly visible not only in elections but also in everyday life. While we often hear about the escalating political disagreements between Democrats and Republicans as the principal concern regarding polarization, these conflicts are only one symptom of a much larger problem: a society that is losing its ability to understand people whose experiences differ from their own. 

Since the 1970s, political polarization has grown to the point of being one of the defining issues of American life in 2026. Elections, social media, news outlets, and even family gatherings often reflect deep ideological divisions. But polarization is no longer confined to politics. It influences where people live, which schools we attend, how wealth is distributed, and even how we understand each other. Reading Sophocles’s Antigone alongside Frederick Douglass’s Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave this summer helped me realize that polarization itself is not always the problem. Democracies need disagreement. The real danger arises when disagreement becomes inflexible, or when a society becomes unwilling to confront injustice. Sophocles warns that communities collapse when leaders refuse to listen, while Douglass reminds us that some forms of injustice should never be accepted simply for the sake of compromise. Together, these works suggest that healthy democracies require both openness to dialogue and the courage to defend justice.  

Before exploring these texts, it is important to understand what political polarization actually means. Polarization occurs when groups move farther apart in their beliefs and become less willing to understand or cooperate with one another. Political polarization is not a new phenomenon in American history. During Richard Nixons’s presidency, his administration deliberately appealed to divisions within American society in what they termed “positive polarization,” demonstrating how political differences could be strategically intensified for political purposes (Krull). Some disagreement is healthy because it encourages debate and forces societies to consider different perspectives. Problems arise when disagreement turns into hostility, when compromise is viewed as weakness and when people stop believing that those on the other side have anything valuable to contribute. Inflexibility can prevent societies from solving problems, while endless compromise can also become dangerous if it requires accepting injustice. The challenge is learning when compromise strengthens democracy and when moral conviction should take priority. This tension between compromise and conviction is not unique to modern democracies; as the books I read this summer demonstrate, it is a question that has challenged societies for millenia.

Almost 2500 years ago, Sophocles explored the tension between compromise and conviction through the conflict between Antigone and King Creon in the first of his Theban plays, Antigone. After a civil war divides Thebes, Creon orders that Polyneices, Antigone’s brother who fought against Thebes, be left unburied because he fought against the city. Antigone refuses, believing that honoring her brother’s body in death is a sacred responsibility that no king has the right to forbid. While Antigone and Creon disagree with one another over the law, Sophocles shows that the tragedy grows worse because Creon refuses to listen to anyone who challenges him. Creon’s son Haemon, who is engaged to Antigone, argues with his father to consider the opinions of the people. The prophet Tiresias warns him that the gods reject his decision. Even the Chorus expresses concern. Yet Creon dismisses every voice except his own. He refuses to move closer to anyone else’s beliefs, and his certainty becomes his greatest weakness. As he declares, “when the city takes a leader, you must obey, / Whether his commands are trivial, or right, or wrong” (Sophocles 666-667). 

Sophocles’ warning feels remarkably relevant today, as American politics have become increasingly defined by a similar ideological certainty. Democrats and Republicans often view one another with suspicion instead of curiosity. This division can be seen in recent congressional conflicts, including the contentious hearing involving Dr. Anthony Fauci this summer. Republican lawmakers aggressively questioned Fauci over his handling of the COVID-19 pandemic and its origins, while Democrats criticized the proceedings as politically motivated. Online commenters then inflamed the division. Social media algorithms reinforce existing beliefs by showing people information they are already likely to agree with, while partisan news sources encourage audiences to distrust other perspectives. Americans increasingly rely on particular outlets as their main sources of political news. A 2025 Pew Research Center survey found that 57% of  Republicans and Republican-leaning independents regularly get news from Fox News, making it the most commonly used news source among Republicans by a wide margin. Among Democrats and Democrat-leaning independents, 48% regularly use CNN, 47% NBC,  and 46% ABC News. The divide becomes even clearer when looking at trust: 56% of Republicans trust Fox as a news source,while 64% of Democrats distrust it. Meanwhile 58% of Democrats trust CNN, with 58% of Republicans distrusting it. As a result, many Americans no longer disagree only about policy; they disagree about facts, motives, and whether the other side deserves to be heard at all. Like Creon, political leaders and citizens alike increasingly mistake confrontation and inflexibility for strength, when in reality refusing to listen to opposing perspectives only deepens division. 

Today polarization extends far beyond elections to wholly shape the way Americans live. One form of this polarization is residential segregation, both historical and modern, which has separated communities by race and income for generations. In cities like Chicago, the legacy of discriminatory housing practices can still be seen in neighborhoods with vastly different schools, public resources, and economic opportunities. These divisions are also reflected in American classrooms. According to the U.S. Government Accountability Office, during the 2020–21 school year, more than a third of public-school students—about 18.5 million—attended schools where at least 75 percent of students were from a single racial or ethnic group. The GAO also found that 14 percent of students attended schools where at least 90 percent of students were from a single racial or ethnic group. Gentrification has added still another layer to this divide. While investment can improve neighborhoods, it can also displace long-time residents and create new barriers between communities. When individuals rarely interact with those whose lives are different from their own, stereotypes become easier to believe and empathy becomes harder to develop. 

Economic polarization displays a similar pattern. The gap between executive compensation and the wages of many workers has exploded over the past several decades. In 1978, CEOs of major American companies were paid about 31 times as much as a typical worker. By 2024, that ratio had snowballed to 281 times as much (Bivens).  Increasingly unequal economic opportunities are making it harder for people from different socioeconomic backgrounds to understand one another’s experiences. Education then further exacerbates these divisions as schools differ dramatically in funding, resources, and opportunities depending on where students live. All these forms of separation reinforce political polarization because they reduce the shared experiences that help citizens understand one another.  

Given all these factors, an American reading Antigone today might conclude that meeting in the middle, or compromise, is always the answer. But a close reading of Frederick Douglass–one of our homegrown literary heroes–complicates that conclusion. His 1845 memoir Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave demonstrates that some systems are so fundamentally unjust that settling only prolongs suffering. At that time, slavery was legal, but its legality did not make it moral. Douglass understood that education was dangerous to slaveholders because it gave enslaved people the ability to recognize the injustice of slavery and to imagine freedom. His master even warned his mistress that it was “unlawful as well as unsafe, to teach a slave to read” (Douglass 37). But rather than encouraging people to simply accept existing laws for stability, Douglass argues that ethical advancement requires challenging authority. 

Douglass therefore makes the reader question one of the conclusions Sophocles presents: if compromise is valuable, are there situations where compromise becomes morally wrong? History suggests that there are. Few people today would argue that slavery should have been preserved through political compromise simply to reduce conflict. 

The question remains relevant today. Debates surrounding healthcare, housing, affordability, food insecurity, immigration, and other issues involving basic human needs continue to challenge Americans to consider where compromises should end and moral responsibility should begin. Citizens may disagree with the best policies, but these disagreements should remain grounded in the recognition that every person deserves dignity and respect. Respectful disagreements do not require people to abandon their beliefs; instead, it requires them to listen to opposing viewpoints and perspectives and search for solutions that acknowledge the concerns of both sides. Chicago recently provided an example of this kind of disagreement when Chicago Public Schools and the Chicago Teachers Union disagreed over whether schools should close for a May Day protest in 2026. The teachers wanted to attend the protest while the school district preferred to keep the schools open. Rather than allowing the disagreement to prevent civic participation or disrupt the school calendar entirely, the two sides reached a compromise that schools should be kept open, with students and teachers who wished to protest able to attend an afternoon rally. 

Reading Sophocles and Frederick Douglass together changed the way I think about political polarization. Before reading these works, I believed the solution was simply for people in this country to compromise more often. While I still believe there are many instances in which we need to be more willing to meet in the middle, now in 2026, I know the solution is more complicated. Sophocles teaches us that societies become dangerous when people refuse to listen to one another, and especially when leaders refuse to listen to anyone but yes men. Douglass teaches us that societies also become–or remain–dangerous when people refuse to confront injustice. Democracy requires both virtues at the same time. We must remain open to changing our minds when confronted with new evidence, but we should also be willing to defend fundamental principles of justice when those principles are threatened by our laws and policies. 

This lesson extends beyond politics. One of the simplest ways to reduce polarization is by intentionally building relationships with people whose backgrounds differ from our own. I experienced this recently with a neighbor who was concerned that our neighborhood was becoming more liberal. As a conservative, he worried that the political changes around him would bring ideologies he did not agree with to his community. I disagreed with his concerns and told him that I did not think the changes would be as negative as he feared and that communities, like everything else, naturally change over time. Although I did not change his mind, nor did he lead me to abandon my perspective, the conversation reminded me that disagreement does not have to lead to hostility. I have also seen young people from different cultural backgrounds, including Polish and Mexican communities in Chicago, come together through schools, sports, and neighborhood activities. These interactions demonstrate that personal relationships often succeed where political arguments fail because they encourage empathy before judgment. 

America will probably never end political polarization, nor should it. Healthy democracies depend on healthy disagreement. The challenge is ensuring that this disagreement strengthens, rather than weakens, society. Throughout recorded history, this challenge appears again and again. Thankfully, we can turn to earlier writings like Antigone and Douglass’s Narrative to understand how societies can navigate the tension between compromise and conviction. Sophocles reminds us that certainty without humility can destroy communities, while Douglass reminds us that peace without justice is not true peace at all. Looking back on that drive through the Southside, I no longer see only neighborhoods separated by economics or history. I also see opportunities for connection. We may not all have the opportunity to question witnesses before Congress, but we can ask questions of those in our communities with different perspectives than our own and listen respectfully to the answers. We must reduce polarization not only during elections, but also in the everyday choices we make to listen, learn and engage with those whose experiences differ from our own. The future of democracy may depend less on convincing everyone to agree and more on learning when to compromise, when to listen, and when to stand firm.  

Works Cited 

Bivens, Josh, Elise Gould, and Jori Kandra. “CEO Pay.” Economic Policy Institute, 25 Sept. 2025, https://www.epi.org/publication/ceo-pay/.

Douglass, Frederick. The Portable Frederick Douglass. Edited by Henry Louis Gates Jr. and John Stauffer, Penguin Classics, 2016.  

Krull, John. “Commentary: Richard Nixon and the Fights That Followed.” The Statehouse File, 5 Aug. 2014, updated 1 Oct. 2021, https://www.thestatehousefile.com/commentary/commentary-richard-nixon-and-the-fights-that-followed/article_79db70e1-4ad7-504e-ac74-c7528ae14e1b.html.

Shearer, Elisa, et al. “The Political Gap in Americans’ News Sources.” Pew Research Center, 10 June 2025, https://www.pewresearch.org/journalism/2025/06/10/the-political-gap-in-americans-news-sources/.

Sophocles. Antigone. Translated by Paul Woodruff, Hackett Publishing Company, 2001.

Talisse, Robert B. “When Is Political Polarization Good and When Does It Go Bad?” Greater Good Magazine, 16 Apr. 2024, https://greatergood.berkeley.edu/article/item/when_is_political_polarization_good_and_when_does_it_go_bad.

United States Government Accountability Office. U.S. Government Accountability Office. https://www.gao.gov/.