Editor’s Note:
This reflection essay was written by Teagle Humanities Fellow Dawoud Chaudhary in August, 2026. During the summer before his first year in college, Dawoud worked with a writing mentor while he read transformative texts, developed his own thoughts and opinions about the world he inhabits, and practiced college-level writing. All of the essays produced in the Teagle Humanities Fellowship are the works of young scholars, and as such, reflect craftsmanship and ideas still in progress, and are written in the spirit of open inquiry.
Dawoud Chaudhary

Dawoud Chaudhary

Dawoud Chaudhary grew up in the Bronx and went to Fordham Prep, a Catholic private high school. He participated in Columbia’s Freedom & Citizenship program in the summer of 2025. He currently attends Fordham University and studies Classical Civilization and Philosophy. He enjoys reading non-fiction, playing and collecting figures from his favorite video games, and is a basketball enthusiast.

“Every Rational Soul does indeed Consult”: Augustine on Knowledge, Reason, and Faith

“His deepest questions about truth and meaning are not Catholic questions; they are human questions. His answers are his own, rooted in his tradition. However, they can be valuable in other traditions as well.”

“For Thou madest us for Thyself, and our heart is restless, until it repose in Thee” (Confessions, Book I, Ch. I). I first encountered this line in my English class, a course framed around the Hero’s journey. We analyzed the work in class, through excerpts, secularly, in the context of St. Augustine’s journey toward a more fully realized version of himself. However, I decided to read the full text on my own. I was drawn to it most notably through this line. Augustine’s total reliance on God left me dumbfounded.

When I read it in full later in the semester, my teacher came up to me, noticeably confused. He thought I didn’t know that we were done with Augustine for the year, and asked why I was reading it. Once he and other peers learned that I was reading it out of interest, the response was almost always similar to something like “Aren’t you Muslim?” The underlying implication was that Augustine was for the Catholics. After all, he is a foundational doctor of the Church. Through my experience with Augustine’s Confessions, Against the Academicians, and The Teacher, I would argue something different: Augustine offers an extremely compelling framework of monotheistic faith, reason, knowledge, and the connection between these concepts to anyone who has felt that same restlessness.

Growing up in an Islamic and low-income, marginalized neighborhood, I had learned to see God as a helping hand. When the world seemed unfair, faith in God became an anchor for my parents, and by extension, me. I learned to see those five daily prayers as a way to disconnect ourselves from this world and be with God. Memorizing Quranic verses as a child felt like connecting to a secret tradition between myself and something vast and beyond me. So, when my English class assigned Augustine, I didn’t expect any connection to be made.

Reading the Confessions in full dismantled these long-standing habits for me. His restlessness was only resolved through a recognition of the omnipresence of God in his life. God had been the object of every desire he’d ever had. Even the disordered ones–those were a result of the absence of God. Augustine did not retreat into his faith and leave the world behind; rather, he found God woven into every hunger, pursuit, and passion. 

I started to reorient everything that I pursued towards my faith. My passion throughout high school and now college has been studying the Greco-Romans through Classical Languages. Studying their philosophy, literature, and intellectual tradition through their language allowed me to better find my place in the world. I admired and internalized Plato’s ideas of the Good and Virgil’s moral weight, but the ideas in the context of a polytheistic pagan tradition created a wall I couldn’t cross–until I read the Confessions. He showed me that reason itself was a form of longing, and this longing can bend towards God. Faith and reason were two separate fields I learned to love, but Augustine made me realize they were the same journey towards one truth. 

I could now bring my whole self into the study of the ancient world instead of leaving faith at the door. Aeneas’ submission to a fate larger than himself started to feel less foreign to me–I now viewed this greater force as God. I also recognized Plato’s Good in the Republic that he reached for as God. My experience growing up led me to have the idea that connection with God was a scheduled event we arrived at the door for. The Confessions expanded my view dramatically. He showed me that everything I love, study, revere, and hope to become is part of the same search I’ve been on all along. 

My interest in Augustine continued, and this past summer I chose to read two texts that come from an earlier period in Augustine’s intellectual development. As someone who was about to do a lot of philosophy work in college, I wanted to know how Augustine was led to his faith through his knowledge of philosophy. While I saw the Confessions as the most significant to my intellectual and theological development, his other two works, Against the Academicians and The Teacher, changed how I saw the pursuit of knowledge and truth in relation to God.

Against the Academicians begins as an epistemological debate, but ends with a connection to God. Augustine argues against the New Academy’s philosophical view that certainty is impossible in any experience, so the wise man should never assent to anything because he can never be certain of it. Alternatively, they admit that the wise man should live through verisimilitude, or truth-likeness, in practical situations. For example, if a tiger runs at you, the wise man is not certain it’s a tiger, but out of fear that it actually is, he should label it as truth-like and treat it as a tiger. The idea of verisimilitude is explained nicely through Augustine’s recounting: “by introducing a kind of probability which they even mentioned as being similar to truth, they maintained that the wise man was in no way negligent in his duties since he had that which he was striving for; truth, however, lay hidden” (38). This was in response to the claim that the wise man can grow weak and neglectful because he can’t confirm anything as true or certain. Through introducing the idea of verisimilitude, the New Academy was allowed to be practical while maintaining a barrier of uncertainty in everything that’s done.

Augustine argues against this logic by contending that there are things we can be certain about. He gives the example of metaphysical axioms, saying “I hold as certain either that there is or is not one world; and if there is not one, there are either a finite or an infinite number of worlds” (Augustine 65). Augustine posits that even if we’re not completely sure about something, we can deduce the problem down to two options. Knowing that there are two options for a problem is certain knowledge that’s valuable in itself. While we don’t know how many worlds there are for certain, it can either be a finite or infinite amount; either way, the world exists. Augustine also introduces mathematical certainties that remain objectively true irrespective of human observation. He highlights the objectivity of basic arithmetic: “for that three threes are nine and represent the square of intelligible numbers is necessary or would be true even though the human race were lying prostrate” (67). Despite what anyone could argue, likely in bad faith, about being unable to verify certain calculations as true, the answers have been and will always remain the same. 

Augustine used the Skeptics’ own logic against themselves to lead into his final point about God. Accepting authority does not clash with reason, but rather allows reason to pursue even greater heights and break the barrier towards finding real Truth. Augustine views the ultimate authority on what is true and certain as God. In his closing statements, he says, “no one doubts that we are incited to learn by the double weight of authority and of reason. Therefore I am sure that I shall never depart from the authority of Christ; for I find no other more reliable. But what ought to be attained by the most subtle reasoning…I trust I shall find meanwhile in the works of the Platonists, what is not in contradiction with our sacred writings” (Augustine 81). Authority and reason are not in opposition for Augustine but complementary. Authority (Christ) establishes the ground and allows reason to pursue truth within it. Augustine believes these central tenets of the world need to be confirmed and agreed upon, especially through faith, so that the search for truth can go somewhere and not end before it even starts. 

The Teacher highlights Augustine’s point about needing God to pursue truth. This work is a dialogue between Augustine and his son Adeodatus. Adeodatus drives the dialogue, arguing that when we speak, we teach people of things or remind them of what they already knew. Augustine pushes him on this. Together, they conclude that words don’t inherently teach anything, but are rather markers that point inwards. When someone speaks, they enable an inner transformation that allows you to find truth. 

This leads into his main argument and theological integration, as Augustine argues that the only true teacher is Christ. Augustine states, “He is who teaches us, namely, Christ, that is to say, ‘the unchangeable Power of God and everlasting wisdom.’ This is the Wisdom which every rational soul does indeed consult, but it reveals itself to each according to his capacity to grasp it by reason of the good or evil dispositions of his will” (Augustine 51). Augustine presents the climax of his dialogue here. He’s been trying to lead his son to the idea that all humans have a disposition to look inwards to find truth. The phrasing Augustine uses, “every rational soul does indeed consult,” is extremely intentional. Augustine is not referring to a specific type of soul, i.e., Catholic, Christian, etc. He refers to souls with the capacity for reason, making this a universal claim. This Wisdom is what all human minds are reaching toward whenever they reason toward truth at all. He is describing the inner teacher as something woven into the structure of rational thought itself. 

A general underlying principle is woven through all three of these texts: the need to orient yourself towards something beyond yourself. Against the Academicians argues that you need to find a foundation to ground yourself in to seek truth. The Teacher insists that no external channels can lead you to true realization–it must be found within an inner teacher. Confessions is a conduit for all these ideas in lived experience, narrating the experiences of a person who doubted, searched, and found truth within through God. His deepest questions about truth and meaning are not Catholic questions; they are human questions. His answers are his own, rooted in his tradition. However, they can be valuable in other traditions as well. Reading and studying Augustine has not led me away from Islam, but rather has let me grow an infinitely deeper sense of appreciation for God.

Works Cited

Augustine, Against the Academicians and The Teacher. Trans. Peter King. Hackett, 1995.