Editor’s Note:
This reflection essay was written by Teagle Humanities Fellow Joseph Kohrs in August, 2026. During the summer before his first year in college, Joseph worked with a writing mentor while he read transformative texts, developed his own thoughts and opinions about the world he inhabits, and practiced college-level writing. All of the essays produced in the Teagle Humanities Fellowship are the works of young scholars, and as such, reflect craftsmanship and ideas still in progress, and are written in the spirit of open inquiry.
Joseph Kohrs

Joseph Kohrs

Joseph Kohrs hails from the Shenandoah Valley in Virginia. He participated in the Bridgewater College Future Scholars Institute in 2025, where he learned a lot about philosophy and the aftermath of the Spanish Civil War through A Long Petal of the Sea by Isabel Allende. He graduated from Massanutten Regional Governor’s School and received an Associates in Arts and Sciences from Laurel Ridge Community College in 2026. He currently attends Swarthmore College. Joseph enjoys reading and writing, fencing, and dabbles in photography and other arts.

The Divided Cemeteries of Mount Jackson, Virginia: How Mythology, Memorial, and Education Collide in Today’s South

“Education remains the foundation of American democracy, the key to ensuring future generations realize what is fact and what is mythology.”

On the Lee-Jackson Memorial Highway, which threads together towns up and down the Shenandoah Valley, lies the weathered stone statue of a Confederate Soldier, bowing his head in remembrance of his comrades. Few wonder what lies within the Confederate-spangled gates of Our Soldier’s Cemetery, as the roadside historical plaque cements its meaning in Lost Cause architecture: “dedicated on 10 May 1866, the third anniversary of Stonewall Jackson’s death.” Upon its creation by the United Daughters of the Confederacy, children and ex-Confederates marched ¾ of a mile towards the cemetery to place wreaths and flags on all 400 graves, after extensive preparations the day before. This tradition of the community’s children and veterans placing flags continued for decades; however, now a chapter of their descendants, the Sons of Confederate Veterans, oversees it—ensuring that every Memorial Day, the cemetery is speckled with 400 carefully placed Confederate battle flags to commemorate the dedication in 1866.

Behind this cemetery lies an unmarked field containing hundreds more graves with only an abandoned railroad track to separate them. Again, few wonder about this field on Nelson Street, if they even spy it from the main road, but for a different reason. It takes a visitor driving across the track down Nelson Street, getting out of one’s car, walking a short dirt road to a partial opening in the wooden fence, and wiping forgotten layers of dust off of cracked gravestones. Only after doing so, does one realize that these are the graves of enslaved people from a nearby plantation, as well as the many Mount Jackson area African Americans who were buried there until the 1970s. No mention of the grave site appears on the other cemetery’s state-erected historical marker. This is the Mount Jackson Colored Cemetery, created because the Union Church Cemetery in Mount Jackson refused to bury African American residents. To the town’s credit, some amount of maintenance is provided to keep grass from overflowing and the descriptive stone in decent shape, though the budget for a statue, flags, metal fencing, marker on main street, or even some sort of civic recognition seems intended solely for those who fought to keep them enslaved. Even the memorial stone itself, despite support from Black residents and the Shenandoah Valley Black Heritage Project in Harrisonburg, was only ever erected because an Eagle Scout from another county needed a project.

The juxtaposition of these two cemeteries is a jarring metaphor for the problem of Civil War memory in modern Southern culture. If the North won, how did the South come to have such a positive narrative about the meaning of the war, and why did that narrative overpower the testimonies of the enslaved and Black soldiers? How did one narrative become central and worthy of celebration, while the other was pushed to the margins? The physical state and location of each cemetery demonstrates which narrative dominated the town’s collective memory. Veterans’ focus on positive and relatable war stories created the need for forgetting its horrors, while promoting a more memorable mythology. Because African Americans lacked the social or political power that would allow their voice to become a narrative that contradicted the status quo, their experiences fell by the wayside. Confederate veterans are remembered as local heroes, fighting to save the valley from Northern aggression, and the enslaved, at least those with documented names, as faithful servants grateful for a benevolent master. This myth of the Lost Cause radiating from Our Soldier’s Cemetery overpowers the memory of the lives on Nelson Street, which remains as a silent, eternal reminder of the war’s deeper meaning.

The romanticized Lost Cause narrative that put slave-owners’ perspectives at the forefront of history is what came from decades of Blue and Grey fraternity; a culture of reconciliation between White veterans from the North and South. Almost immediately after the war ended, describes historian David Blight in Race and Reunion, two groups of people formed—those who acknowledged that slavery was the cause but refused to promote Black equality, and those who formed the early Lost Cause doctrine of independence and “states’ rights.” In fact, some plantation owners went as far as stating that African Americans were “doomed to extinction” when faced with freedom (Blight 36). A blatant example of Lost Cause proprietorship and White supremacy was Jefferson Davis, president of the Confederate States of America. He shifted from drafting secession documents for the preservation of slavery to preaching the doctrine that slavery was in no way connected to the Civil War itself, in less than ten years. After Davis’s release from prison in 1867, he argued that “Sovereigns cannot rebel,” placing all blame at the foot of the North and spreading propaganda about African Americans’ ancestors being born “the slaves of barbarian masters” and fit for nothing but subservience to Christian masters (Blight 260). In Blight’s words, Davis “gave the Lost Cause its lifeblood” with stories of a “victimized South” with “faithful slaves and benevolent masters” (261). Stories matter, and when unbridled, they turn into belief.

In less than 50 years, those who fought against the United States of America gained a nearly insurmountable hold over the Southern narrative of slavery and the war. The end of the Civil War brought romanticism to an extent the United States had never seen before. Soldiers on both sides, while initially reluctant to share the horrors they had witnessed, rushed to cement their legacy as heroes by publishing narratives and memoirs to outlets like Century magazine. These accounts of the Civil War varied in accuracy and prose, but one thing they all lacked was discussion of slavery or secession (Blight 175). As Blight theorized, the Lost Cause required a great forgetting of the “emancipationist vision,” or a memory of the war through the eyes of Black Americans and Reconstructionists (2). This concept was the basis of his historical work, explaining the absence of Black Americans from such a notable part of American history because they simply lacked the power to influence it. The focus of wartime histories shifted from the emancipation of millions of slaves to White soldiers sharing a beer while chuckling over army stories. Blight aptly describes this as a quasi-mythology; Civil War tales served as depthless glorification where the face value—brave Confederate and Union soldiers fighting for equally just causes—was all there was to see (191). The South had lost the physical war, but it was determined to win the historical war through reconciliation. 

In fact, the Nelson Street cemetery not only proves the South’s competence at winning the war over history but serves as just one example in a county filled with Lost Cause mythology. These ideals from a time glorifying foreign veterans thrive most vividly in New Market, Virginia, where nearly every street memorializes a Confederate general. This town is an essential waypoint on I-81 for truckers needing gas and a destination for travelers who want a Nightingale ice-cream sandwich from the general store; however, it is also the valley haven for Civil War buffs and Confederate lobbying giants. For those looking to enter Page Valley, Route 211 exists as a convenient mountain pass, and historic thoroughfare for enslavers heading towards the jail for runaway slaves and Civil War troops heading toward the Confederacy’s capital at Richmond. One can take a jaunt down Lee Highway to visit Jackson’s Corner Cafe, getting glimpses into glorious battles while sipping a chai latte and reading numerous placards about New Market’s wartime involvement; wander down Ashby Lane to visit the community park, where kids play near houses with antique cannons lying in their yards; and finish out the day with a stroll through the Virginia Museum of the Civil War campus—a high caliber testament to 19th century reconciliationism, where the battle of New Market ended in a decisive victory for the Rebels and defeat for the Union.

Not a single notable aspect of New Market’s memorialization remembers Black figures or even acknowledges slavery as anything besides a coincidence of the time that was already in decline. As the single balancing factor is a downtown placard that highlights the Jessie Ruparts School House for Black students, which focuses on the White educator, one can imagine why the town only has about 50 African American residents today (Census Dots). At the Shenandoah Valley NAACP branch’s 2026 celebration of Juneteenth, held in the nearby town of Edinburg, an African American activist drove up from southern Virginia to speak about his experience pushing for legislation to fight systemic racism at Virginia Military Institute. He had certainly faced terrible remarks and pushback for this activism as well as the color of his skin; however, even he was unprepared for the amount of Confederate iconography present along the Shenandoah County corridor. As this experience illustrates, a Black visitor who stops at Jackson’s Corner cafe in New Market could describe the scene off of Lee Highway as a Lost Cause Disneyland, where memory is not only temporarily commercialized in general store souvenirs, museum-coffee shops, and even Confederate general nutcrackers, but also permanently enshrined in streets and buildings named after generals designated as heroes of the South.

Between New Market and Mount Jackson lies another notoriety: Stonewall Jackson High School. This school today seems relatively inconspicuous—it is just a local high school after all, named after a historical figure. As students filter off their buses into the lobby, things get a little more complicated. Adorning the walls are mementos of Southern school pride flanked by the Guidance office’s row of previous, notably white, Valedictorians and Salutatorians. On the wall adjacent to the office entrance stands a display case with school history in it: an original logo of a grey-cloaked general riding a horse and holding a Confederate flag, founding documents from the 1950s, and a picture of the school with its giant Confederate flag. Next to it is a plaque referencing the school’s dedication, a momentous day for the county’s White students. There is no dedication plaque for the few Black students who integrated the school ten years after Brown v. Board.

In 1959, during a period in Virginia of massive resistance to integration, the school was named Stonewall Jackson High School and dedicated to the county as a “White-only” building. For 61 years, nobody questioned why the first class to integrate was 1963-64, or why not a single photograph on the guidance wall featured an African American student, despite a consistent Black student population of 3% and well over 100 pictures (US News & World Report & SENK). In fact, to find out that the school actively resisted integration, one must comb through years of school board records. African American families thrived only when leaving Shenandoah County for places that felt more receptive to their view of history, or even their very presence. Until the Shenandoah County schools opened to non-White kids, Black students had to figure out how to carpool to Winchester or Harrisonburg or to move to a boarding school in Manassas just to attend high school. Segregation ensured that Black families never gained the chance to question community mythology by forcing them to migrate elsewhere if they wanted to give their children a chance to receive a diploma. 

Segregation did nothing to curb the evolution of ethics over decades, however, and eventually some locals saw through the curtain raised by decades of Lost Cause celebration. Such realization triumphed over opposition, and in 2020, the school board decided that it was time to address part of this systemic racism through renaming. Stonewall Jackson and the nearby elementary school, Ashby Lee, were renamed to Mountain View and Honey Run, respectively. To many, this change represented a county’s desire to heal and scrape up Lost Cause residue from public spaces, and while the next four years were not without naming controversy, the county seemed to be moving forward for once. Without school board comment sections, loud supporters of Confederate symbolism flocked to Facebook and startup newspapers like The Freedom Press to issue their complaints—complaints that seemed irrelevant with such a costly and thus decisive decision. These few loud supporters, however, masked just how many community members were either ambivalent or sympathetic to their cause, and in 2024 school board members went up for election once more. This time, they ran on an agenda: reversing the 2020 decision to rename the southern campus schools. Their successful adoption of this agenda, in a 5-1 vote, solidified the hold that Civil War romanticism had developed through the lens of Southern pride and Confederate veteran ancestry organizations. 

Historically, education is the one place where Lost Cause mythology has never quite managed to fully penetrate—something especially stressed by W. E. B. Du Bois in his book, The Souls of Black Folk. Du Bois was a lot of things, from activist to the first African American Harvard PhD graduate and sociologist. His studies influenced much of the civil rights movement and today’s academic perception of what the post-war era was like for Black Americans. For a short period, Du Bois worked as a teacher at a tiny Black school in Tennessee where, despite a lack of resources, kids’ “weak wings beat against their barriers,—barriers of caste” (Du Bois 56). While he acknowledged that many Black men were in their right to avoid violence on themselves through pacifism, much like the leader Booker T. Washington, his philosophy of education left no room for concessions and little room for a liberal arts experience. Education was the way to transcend this color veil and gain, without opposition or disgust, a seat “with Shakespeare” (83). In this spirit, Du Bois also wrote of Atlanta University that “the true college will ever have one goal,—not to earn meat, but to know the end and aim of that life which meat nourishes” (65). Essentially, education resisted Lost Cause mythology by giving students the ability to critically think about life. 

It is no wonder then that Du Bois disagreed so fundamentally with Washington, who believed that civil rights should come only after African Americans gain vocational training and economic power. White men had control, and until they could be held responsible by a similar economic power, Washington preached that African Americans should work quietly and peacefully toward becoming property owners and businessmen (Du Bois 44). Contrarily, Du Bois saw education as the path to equality and justice, not a way to subject people once again to labor and subservience. He did agree that vocational training was necessary, but only when supplemented by a liberal arts education that could raise thinkers, leaders, and activists who would fight the growing Lost Cause narrative and secure themselves a future. By failing to “state plainly and unequivocally the legitimate demands of their people,” African Americans would shoot themselves, their descendants, and future immigrants in the foot—agitation was not the reason Black Americans faced discrimination, instead it was engrained and unchecked prejudice (46). Lost Cause mythology only applied to history because White veterans remained a more powerful force than educated Black opposition, something severely limited by Washington’s philosophy of silence and self-reliance.

While the Lost Cause still serves as the South’s truth today, because scholars like Du Bois dared to challenge popular war memory and record the experiences of a people who were all but silenced through writing and education, cracks grew in the narrative. Even the White Southern education system, told for 100 years by Confederate groups like the UDC to preach romanticized Civil War history over any Black history, pre-civil rights movement, eventually contradicted itself by teaching kids to think critically. So why did the Lost Cause narrative remain so strong? The answer is simple: mythology never relies on just one place to spread. The schools might directly teach critical thinking, but field trips to the New Market Battlefield and Our Soldier’s Cemetery still happened for elementary schoolers. Middle schoolers still did close readings of pro-Confederate books, such as The Ghost Cadet, a Civil War narrative that casts fallen Confederate soldiers, especially VMI cadets, in a heroic light and downplayed the role of slavery in the war. By the time kids entered high school, their community and environment had ingrained a romantic, depthless Confederate heritage in the teaching of ethics and politics, despite what advanced humanities classes suggested about basing beliefs on unbiased and credible information. 

After years of what can only be described as communal indoctrination, seniors applying to scholarships have the option to get SJHS Alumni & boosters money, but also to apply for the Captain Jack Adams Sons of Confederate Veterans (SCV) Scholarship. This award requires an essay on a Civil War topic, some of which are inconspicuous like the first option, which requires applicants to write about a Confederate relative. Other topics are less so, as the second requires the applicant to describe the war as either one of “Southern independence” or “northern aggression”; the third asks, what the “real reason for the Civil War” is; and the sixth encourages students to ruminate on the “true purpose of the Emancipation Proclamation” (SCPS Scholarships). The agenda, teaching students a very specific narrative about the Civil War that ignores slavery and Black experience, could not be clearer. In fact, Blight confirms the connection between scholarship and Confederate agenda during his discussion of the United Daughters of the Confederacy (UDC). Prior to 1900, the UDC actively rewrote history textbooks with faithful slave imagery, held youth essay contests for Civil War topics, and donated thousands of scholarship dollars to Confederate descendants (Blight 273).  Today, the SCV holds the same goals, goals that are equally apparent in the bias of their scholarship and speeches. Their senior award ceremony speech—an event that happens once a year in front of the entire student body—culminates with descriptions of the life, heroism, and relevancy of Confederate general Jack Adams, as well as Stonewall Jackson. Education should teach critical thinking, but it could not prevent an entire community from corrupting the data on which alumni had learned to think critically, making the school name reversal decision of 2024 inevitable.

One thing stressed by Blight throughout his writing is that while something like a cemetery or a plaque can pass as historical preservation, the naming of public spaces and even the dedication of statues are primarily ways to memorialize. Naming an avenue for a Confederate general when a Civil War museum or battlefield is its feature is not necessarily problematic. When a town names every major road and monument after Confederate generals, or a school board dedicates a public school to one and invites Confederate donors, scholarships, and imagery with open arms, it becomes more than just a memory. In fact, it becomes the antithesis of historical preservation, as memorialization without the context of the life or ideals of a person is simply mythology. Jackson, Lee, and Ashby could have been considered good Christians or powerful military leaders, but when people chose specifically those aspects of their character for memorialization and ignore their brutality, racism, or unethical life decisions, they exit the purview of history.

In objection to Confederate mythology, Shenandoah County’s new, heavily-biased school board was legally forced by five of their own students and the Virginia NAACP to reckon with their reversal of the 2020 school renaming decision. This lawsuit focused on several different amendments, but its main arguments focused on the fact that Black and White students who live in districts served by one public school are both forced to be represented by that school’s name and memory. When that memory represents a set of morals that is harmful to those of today, students face no choice but to put up with it or move away from the county where they live, just like the community’s Black residents had to do before integration. These students recognized this wrong, and fought to correct it. Like them, I had no choice but to attend Stonewall Jackson High School, a building originally named to memorialize an outdated, harmful moral code, and suppress Black students who wished to integrate. I spoke at school board meetings, endured glares and mocking comments when other students realized that I rejected a status quo that they never dared to question, and I felt heartened when others also acknowledged the harm memorialization of the Confederacy can cause. Time allowed me to realize that even if part of one’s community itself refuses to reconcile with their beliefs again and again, there is always hope for those who are younger to not slip through the cracks.

While time showed that racism can always get worse, it also proved that activists like Frederick Douglass and W. E. B. Du Bois were right to never give up hope on the advancement of civil rights and documentation of Black experience in the South. Du Bois might describe Confederate memory as the descendant of Southern color prejudice, something that must be recognized as a fact that “stands in the way of civilization and religion and common decency.” He writes that the only way to combat such prejudice is “by the breadth and broadening of human reason” (Du Bois 71). The time of reconstruction, in all its complexity, brought education into the South, creating a new generation of Americans that had the potential to innovate and question. Education remains the foundation of American democracy, historically paving the way for Black suffrage across the country. It remains the key to ensuring future generations realize what is fact and what is mythology.

A veil still rests upon America today, ever present in discussions of the Civil War and the education of students. Some may call it blasphemy to suggest there is depth hidden beneath it, others an attack against their values, but, like the Confederate battle flag hanging outside of a southern high school in 1959, it was bound to decay with time. Residents of Shenandoah County, and the South in general, have been infatuated with the mythology of the Lost Cause since Jefferson Davis realized from his jail cell that the war for history had begun. For the most part, the eventual sidelining of Black experience, dismissal of slavery as the Civil War’s leading cause, and promotion of hate as heritage was no fault of everyday Southerners—in a time of little education and terrible communication, they believed what they heard and saw, which were exclusively White voices. Only until the education system began to catch up, could students begin to see through the cracks in the Southern narrative. The soldier in Our Soldier’s Cemetery bows his head, the modern figurehead of those voices that lament a lost cause, yet, he is also a Confederate veil, one that distracts from the malleability of history. Behind this veil, the graveyard on Nelson Street holds fast, challenging the myth of the Lost Cause for those who can find it.

Works Cited

Blight, David. Race and Reunion: The Civil War in American Memory. President and Fellows of Harvard College, 2001.

Census Dots. “New Market, VA Demographics.” Census Dots, 2024, https://www.censusdots.com/race/new-market-va-demographics.

Du Bois, W. E. B. The Souls of Black Folk. W. W. Norton & Company, 1999.

Kohrs, Sarah. “52 Weeks Blog.” SENK, 2023, https://www.senkohrs.com/52-weeks-blog.

Shenandoah County Public Schools. “SJHS Scholarships.” SCPS Scholarships, 2025, https://sites.google.com/shenandoah.k12.va.us/scpsscholarships/sjhs-scholarships?authuser=0.

US News and World Report. “Mountain View High.” Usnews.Com, 2026, https://www.usnews.com/education/best-high-schools/virginia/districts/shenandoah-county-public-schools/mountain-view-high-20626.