What creates the self? Are we born as who we are, or are we a compilation of expectations pressed upon us by society? The foundation of the self is built by citizens’ willingness to sacrifice for the collective good. Nations create institutions to provide a groundwork for society to function. Those structures may create opportunities for intellectual pursuit; however, these foundations themselves depend on individual sacrifice. Sigmund Freud, an Austrian neurologist and the founder of psychoanalysis, examines how civilization requires individuals to abandon or regulate their desires for social order in Civilization and Its Discontents in 1930. He presents social regulation as necessary for the development of civilization. Fifty years later, Richard Rodriguez, in Hunger of Memory, reveals the personal costs that are sacrificed to sustain these structures. Moreover, society provides the framework necessary for intellectual advancement while the benefits of that advancement come with limitations on individual freedom. Through both texts, Freud examines the suppression necessary for civilization to continue, while Rodriguez reveals how these expectations become racialized, requiring people of color to suppress aspects of their cultural identity to be a part of Western civilization.
In Civilization and Its Discontents, Freud presents a ladder of development from the individual to the communal structure necessary for protection and development. Individuals are born in a natural state with what Freud describes as an “oceanic feeling,” or the yearning to be connected with something limitless, beyond understanding, like God (Freud 11). Freud’s discussion of “infantile helplessness” establishes that people are not born self-sufficient, which creates a desire for protection and security (Freud 21). This dependence extends beyond childhood as individuals start to rely on social laws and structures. Because people are inherently vulnerable, they seek structures that provide protection, but in relying on them, they must accept rules and limitations. Establishing laws creates a boundary around individual behavior, as Freud argues that boundaries are needed to restrain the “primary mutual hostility of human beings” because, without such restraint, “civilized society is perpetually threatened with disintegration” (Freud 69). Formalized Western education is a prime example of this development because, as people gain safety, they are able to pursue intellectual and cultural knowledge. Freud praises the achievements produced through western civilization because it has shown true progress. He described Western civilization as reaching a “high water mark” in its development (Freud 60).
Furthermore, the creation of schooling created progression within society. It demonstrates how civilization has turned social stability into technological and medical progress. Freud’s argument that the “first step towards attaining intellectual mastery of our environment is to discover generalizations, rules and laws which bring order into chaos” suggests that knowledge gives individuals greater control over an unpredictable world. This explains that as we create more technology that mimics human intelligence, there is a decreasing trust in traditional religion. Schooling allows knowledge to exist beyond the individual through generations. As one generation learns, that knowledge can be preserved and passed to the next. This shows that civilization can extend individuals beyond the limits of their own lifetime. However, for intellectual progression to continue, it depends upon the same social order that restricts individual behavior.
Freud argues that civilization teaches us to suppress our human desires and “primal urges.” According to Freud, the “id” represents the unconscious, most intimate, part of the personality driven by primitive desires and impulses. The “id” seeks satisfaction through hedonism, violence, and sexual conquests, and civilization must regulate these urges to maintain social structures. If civilization allows us to move beyond immediate desires in seeking education and intellectual development, what else must the individual relinquish in order to achieve that development? While Freud examines the benefits and sacrifices needed for civilization to maintain social order, Richard Rodriguez shows how these costs disproportionately fall on people of color and immigrants whose most intimate identities are at odds with what Western Civilization praises.
Rodriguez’s real-life experience with his educational journey provides a deep personal example of the demands Freud discusses. For Rodriguez, education was not simply a path to intellectual development, but was the system through which he understood himself and his life in the public commons. As a young child of Mexican immigrants, Rodriguez was split between a private life at home and his public life at school. A language barrier separated the two; while Spanish connected him to his family and culture, English became necessary for his education and social development. Rodriguez’s growing fluency in English allowed him to participate more in the public world; however, it created a separation from the intimacy he shared with his family.
Rodriguez, being one of the largest advocates against bilingual education, mimics much of the contemporary rhetoric around using Spanish in public seen today. He describes a moment sitting on the bus when he fully sees himself as an “American,” no longer an “alien” in “gringo society,” and now able to seek the “rights and opportunities” necessary for “full public individuality” (Rodriguez 26-27). This process of the individual ego being subsumed by society aligns closely with Freud’s vision of how civilization functions. Although English gave him access to pursue education, it also taught him to shun the parts of himself which were once the most important and known aspects of his sense of self. His use of the word “alien” suggests that in adopting American civilization, he was forced not to just suppress his “id” but to see it as inhuman entirely. As Freud suggests, the “public world” that Rodriguez wants to enter comes at the expense of his infantile self, but unlike white or American-born students, these are not universal urges that are suppressed, but total alienation from who he was as a Spanish-speaking child.
Much like how Freud acknowledges the argument that “civilization is largely responsible for our misery,” the systems created to protect individuals are also those which we most rage against because they are all we know (Freud 38). However, both men critique this mindset and align closer with a logic that Western Civilization should be praised because of its quantitative knowledge. In Rodriguez’s experience, his participation in American society provided opportunities for intellectual development but also contributed to his severing from his family and culture.
As Rodriguez grew older, his two worlds increasingly separated. He felt embarrassed by his parents’ lack of formal education and envious of his light-skinned brother (Rodriguez). These feelings ultimately reveal how the educational and white social standards surrounding him began to influence how he viewed himself and his family. Rodriguez began to measure his parents according to the standards of the educated society, which was populated by wealthy and white Stanford alumni, that he entered. Rodriguez emphasizes that he trusts a society that is structured by authority, although his personal experiences reveal that these institutions were created to intentionally exclude people like his parents who were born without the resources to access them. Why does Rodriguez choose to believe in a society that depends on structure and authority to function? Does this social order also pressure individuals to conform? For Rodriguez, conformity is not racially neutral, as the standards he seeks to enter are shaped by a wealthy and predominantly white society. Rodriguez’s upbringing is important to understanding the conflict between intellectual pursuit, belonging, and individuality, as well as the suppression Freud describes as necessary to be a part of civilization.
However, the ideas presented by Freud and Rodriguez extend beyond their individual experiences and can be applied to ongoing questions of self-conception and belonging among Hispanic Americans. For many Hispanic Americans, the pressures of assimilation can create conflict within their cultural identity and social belonging. Although education and fluency in English can open doors, they can also close others by creating pressures to distance oneself from traditions, language, and cultural background. Research shows that not all Hispanic Americans experience their identity in the same way. According to statistics, 41% of Hispanic Democrats are more likely to say that being Hispanic makes it harder to get ahead in the United States, while 22% of Hispanic Republicans are more likely to say that being Hispanic makes it harder to succeed (Piña). The different percentages among Hispanic Democrats and Republicans demonstrate how Hispanic self-identification differs in America. Instead, they show how political and social perspectives influence whether individuals view their Hispanic background as a barrier to or a part of their success. This further illustrates that cultural identity is shaped by individuals’ understanding of their place within American society.
The pressures, whether felt or unfelt, also intensify across generations of Hispanic Americans. According to a study, 97% of first-generation and 92% of second-generation adults identify themselves as Hispanic, compared with 77% of third-generation adults and only 50% in the fourth or later generations (Piña). At the same time, the percentage of Latinos who identify as American is increasing across generations. These changes show how identities can shift over time as individuals become more integrated into society. This pattern raises the question of whether assimilation involves some degree of cultural negotiation or sacrifice. Tying into Freud’s concept of the id, this helps us understand the tension between individual desire and the demands of society. In the same way that civilization places limits on desires, assimilation creates expectations about how individuals should identify themselves. Furthermore, this can be seen as evidence of successful integration by allowing generations to embrace an American identity without abandoning their background. However, it also shows a decline in Hispanic self-identification, suggesting that this integration involves changes in how cultural identity is preserved and expressed.
In both texts, Freud and Rodriguez examine the relationship between individuals and society; however, their lack of empathy or acknowledgment of the cost borne by people of the dominant society shows that these sacrifices are heavily racialized. In addition to the primal urges Freud speaks about, non-white Americans are also expected to give up parts of themselves that are not harmful to other individuals. Freud focuses on the demands necessary for civilization, while Rodriguez shows how those expectations can influence a person’s relationship with education, family, and cultural belonging. I understand the reasons Rodriguez has felt this way for many years while growing up. My parents are immigrants, and I understand the struggle of learning English. However, through education, I have found ways to express my identity as a Hispanic American rather than suppress it. Growing up in a diverse setting, I understand that there does not have to be such a shameful split between the private and the public because the American Dream promises the ability to integrate both.
My own experiences have made me recognize that these tensions are not confined to texts, but have made me question whether belonging should always come with expectations of changing yourself. My perspective on this issue has allowed me to understand the reasons for the sacrifices discussed by Freud in becoming part of a civilization and, through Rodriguez, to see a reflection of myself in his story of pursuing intellectual development to become part of the majority. Belonging to a group should not require an individual to sacrifice the differences that shape their identity.
Works Cited
Freud, Sigmund. Civilization and Its Discontents. Translated and edited by James Strachey, W.W. Norton & Company, 1961.
Piña, Gabriel, et al. “Latino Immigrants and U.S.-Born Latinos Differ on How Much Their Identity Shapes Their Lives.” Pew Research Center, Pew Research Center, 9 July 2026, www.pewresearch.org/race-and-ethnicity/2026/07/09/latino-immigrants-and-u-s-born-latinos-differ-on-how-much-their-identity-shapes-their-lives/.
Rodriguez, Richard. Hunger of Memory: The Education of Richard Rodriguez. Bantam Books, 2004.
“Vii. Language Usage, Intermarriage and Generational Status.” Pew Research Center, Pew Research Center, 6 Dec. 2004, www.pewresearch.org/race-and-ethnicity/2004/12/06/vii-language-usage-intermarriage-and-generational-status/.
